Mixed response to J&K dialogue ‘Azad Kashmir isn’t possible as part of it belongs to Pakistan’
VALLEY HUDDLE Interlocutor Sharma met fringe outfits like Bhartiya Modi Army, Rahul Gandhi Fan Club and discussed matters related to use of loudspeakers at religious places
SRINAGAR/JAMMU: When the government named former Intelligence Bureau chief Dineshwar Sharma last month to lead peace talks in Jammu and Kashmir, it was hailed as a watershed moment to end a bloody insurgency that’s claimed more than 40,000 lives.
But Sharma’s five-day visit to the troubled state yielded mixed results, with several prominent parties and trade bodies staying away with sources saying that several of the 80-odd delegations he met comprised fringe groups with little pull in the state.
The 63-year-old, who returned from the Valley on Friday, met outfits such as the Rahul Gandhi Fan Club and Bhartiya Modi Army, and attended to deputations over issues such as the transfer of a tehsildar.
Both the Rahul Gandhi Fan club and Bhartiya Modi Army told Hindustan Times that they were national-level organisations. Rahul Gandhi Fan club chief organiser Mohd Ashraf said the group was formed in 2008. “We have around 2,000 members. We are driven by Rahul Gandhi’s clean youth leader image and membership is voluntary,’’ he said.
Bhartiya Modi Army claims it has at least 20,000 members. “There is no leader like Mr Modi. He is the strongest prime minister India has seen to date...he is a one man army and we want to be his soldiers,’’ said Haroon Nabi Lone, group’s national president who says he joined it in 2015.
Sharma, a 1979 batch IPS officer, will submit a report to the government but no deadline has been declared. The talks are seen as an extension of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Independence Day Kashmir outreach when he said the region’s problems could be solved by embracing its people. Modi’s comments indicated a possible shift in his policy towards Kashmir, which has been largely paralysed since July last year, when the killing of militant leader Burhan Wani sparked widespread violence and clashes that killed around 100 and injured thousands.
Among groups that called on the Centre’s special representative were the little-known Jammu and Kashmir Youth Alliance, a one-man delegation from the Shiv Sena, local NGO Red Winter Youth Organisation, and the J&K Political Migrant Front. Some other organisations listed as political parties were the J and K Watan Parast Party, Rashtriya Manch and Tehreek-e-insaf .
At the same time, prominent trade bodies such as the Kashmir Chamber of Commerce and Industries and Federation Chamber of Industries Kashmir (FCIK) – and even associations of hoteliers and houseboat owners – were absent. “We are traders, if government wants to talk politics they should talk to politicians, we have spoken to people earlier but it’s of no use,’’ said FCIK president Mohammad Ashraf Mir.
Among mainstream political parties, the ruling Peoples Democratic Party called the visit a “significant breakthrough’’ but the Opposition appeared unimpressed. The separatist Hurriyat Conference stayed away from any meeting.
The National Conference (NC) said it had not been invited and party chief Omar Abdullah said his meeting with Sharma was in “personal capacity’’.
Even in Jammu, Sharma had to deal with a raft of issues – including on the use of loudspeakers at religious places. Rakesh Gupta, president of Jammu Chamber of Commerce and Industry along with his team of office bearers, called on Dineshwar Sharma and had “threadbare discussions”. “The use of PI systems (read loudspeakers) at all religious places we feel is a major source of trouble and may lead to communal provocation,” he said. SRINAGAR: The Centre’s new dialogue process will not succeed until India talks to Pakistan as a part of the region belongs to Islamabad, former chief minister Farooq Abdullah said.
He also said on Saturday that the demand for independence was wrong. Abdullah, the leader of National Conference, was responding to queries from media persons on the appoint- ment of Dineshwar Sharma as the Centre’s special representative for dialogues to resolve issues in Kashmir, primarily the three-decade-old insurgency.
“I can only tell that he indulged in dialogue here. But that won’t solve the issue because this is an issue between India and Pakistan,” he said, adding the government of India has to talk to the government of Pakistan. He said that people have to realise that a part of Kashmir is under Indian control and another under Pakistan.
“I tell them in plain terms — not only to Indians but also to the world — that the other side belongs to Pakistan and this side to India. This won’t change. Let them fight as many wars as they want,” he said. “And when the situation is such, they have to talk, so that we live in peace; both parts live in peace; and for that, it is imperative to grant autonomy to both the parts,” he said.
‘INDIA BETRAYED US’ Abdullah also maintained that the demand for azadi by the separatists was wrong and an independent Kashmir was not possible. “All three of them have atom bombs. We have nothing except Allah’s name. Those talking about azadi are talking wrong.”
The NC patron also said India “betrayed” Kashmiris. “India didn’t treat us well… They didn’t recognise the love with which we chose to join them,” he said.