Cong alleges surveillance racket, BJP rejects charge
Congress says Priyanka Gandhi Vadra received message that her phone data was suspected to have been breached
Two political leaders have so far stated that their phones were being tapped and hacked... Priyanka Gandhi Vadra also got one such message.
RANDEEP SURJEWALA ,
Congress’s chief spokesperson
NEW DELHI: The Congress on Sunday said the party’s general secretary, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, was also informed by messaging services company Whatsapp that her phone data was suspected to have been breached, at a time when the firm has admitted there was targeted surveillance of several Indians by an Israeli spyware.
The Congress’s chief spokesperson Randeep Surjewala alleged on Sunday that this indicated the Union government was involved in a “surveillance racket”. The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) hit back, saying the Congress was “imagining things” that do not exist, while Whatsapp said users can contact the company to find out if their accounts were compromised.
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra was also informed by Whatsapp about a possible breach of her phone, Surjewala told reporters at a press conference in response to a question on whether hackers had targeted anyone from the Congress.
Several rights activists, lawyers, and journalists on Thursday said that they had been identified as targets of a phone hack aimed at snooping on them a day after Whatsapp went public with allegations against an Israeli firm for having misused its platform to aid spying on around 1,400 people across the world.
HT on Friday reported that the people targeted in India included former Union minister Praful Patel and ex-lok Sabha member Santosh Bhartiya, and on Sunday that at least 121 people in the country were targets. However, it was not clear how many of these attempts were successful. Of these, 21 were journalists, lawyers, and activists.
Surjewala called the breach a serious issue. “Two political leaders have so far stated that their phones were being tapped and hacked. As far as I know, when Whatsapp was supposedly sending messages to different people that their phones were hacked, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra also got one such message on her phone,” he said.
Surjewala added that Whatsapp did not say that the phone was hacked using illegal Pegasus software. “The nature of the message is already available in the public domain and she also received one such message. I can say only this much,” he said. He alleged that the government is the “deployer and executor” of this “illegal and unconstitutional snooping and spying racket”.
A Congress leader, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said that Priyanka Gandhi got a message from Whatsapp, and not from the Toronto-based research group Citizen Lab as was the case with some other breaches. The Citizen Lab and Whatsapp informed activists such as Anand Teletumbde and Bela Bhatia about the hacking.
BJP’S information technology cell incharge Amit Malviya dismissed Surjewala’s statement. “Haven’t we seen Congress imagining things that don’t exist? remember them claiming that Rahul Gandhi’s life was in danger when a green light, off a video camera, flashed on his face during a media briefing. Well, that is the level of their leaders’ credibility in public life,” he tweeted.
In a statement late on Sunday, a Whatsapp spokesperson said that the company cares deeply about the privacy and security of its users. “Users can contact us within the app and we will respond directly [if their accounts are compromised],” said the spokesperson.
The IT ministry declined to comment on the issue.
The spyware in question is developed by NSO Group and is known mostly as Pegasus, though it has also been sold as Q Suite. Researchers from Citizen Lab have since 2016 assisted potential targets who were spied upon using it – including people linked to murdered Saudi activist Jamal Khashoggi.
Pegasus, technically a malware, allows a near-complete control of a target’s phone, enabling access to files, communications, and even microphone and camera. It can be delivered to targets in several ways, but the method that drew most attention exploited a flaw in Whatsapp’s code that made it possible for the hack to be carried out without any user intervention.
Haven’t we seen Cong imagining things that don’t exist? Remember them claiming that Rahul’s life was in danger when a green light, off a video camera, flashed on his face AMIT MALVIYA ,
BJP’S information technology cell incharge
NEW DELHI: The Congress announced on Sunday that two parliamentary panels, headed by its leaders, will take up the Pegasus hacking attack and seek responses from government officials on the issue.
The standing committee on home affairs, led by Rajya Sabha MP Anand Sharma, and the standing committee on information technology, headed by Lok Sabha MP Shashi Tharoor, will examine the case.
Terming the hacking episode as worrisome, Sharma said the issue will be taken up at the panel’s next meeting, scheduled for November 15.
“In that meeting this issue will also be discussed and we will seek details from the secretary,” news agency PTI quoted Congress leader Sharma as saying.
Tharoor said the panel on information technology would share its concerns with the government.
“In any case cybersecurity is a major issue on our agenda and we are definitely going to take this up under that rubric. And we will be seeking clarifications from the government,” he said.
He also said that India should not become a “surveillance state” like China, adding that India should be wary of its democratic ideals coming under the threat of disruptive technology.
The Home Secretary is scheduled to brief the panel on home affairs on the situation in Jammu and Kashmir in the next meeting. “In that meeting this issue will also be discussed and we will seek details from the secretary,” Sharma said.
NEW DELHI: Taking a grim view of unrestrained criticism of judges on social media for some of their judicial actions, Chief Justice of India designate Justice Sharad Arvind Bobde says it bothers him when he sees judges feeling “harassed” and finds the attack difficult to ignore.
Justice Bobde, who will assume charge as the 47th Chief Justice of India on November 18, also said the unrestricted criticism was not only scandalising but also tearing apart judges’ reputation. Criticism of judges instead of their judgments including on social media is actually an offence of ‘defamation’, Bobde said during a wide-ranging interview with news agency PTI.
Asked whether criticism of judges bothers him, Justice Bobde said, “To an extent. Yes. It bothers me. That it might affect the performance of courts and I see judges who feel harassed. To that extent it bothers me. Nobody likes it. Everybody is not thickskinned enough to ignore. Judges are also normal human beings.” He, however, said the apex court could not do anything to address the uncontrolled criticism.
“What can we do. We cannot do anything to this kind of media as of now. We don’t know what steps to take. They are not only scandalising but tearing apart people’s reputation and judges’ reputation,” he said and sarcastically added, “On top of that, there is a grievance that there is no freedom of speech”.
“Criticising the judge and not judgment is defamation,” said Justice Bobde, who will have a tenure of about 18 months.