Hindustan Times (Jalandhar)

Psychiatry group allows commenting on Trump

- Kartikeya Ramanathan kartikeya.ramanathan@htlive.com

NEWDELHI: The American Psychoanal­ytic Associatio­n has allowed its members to comment on the mental state of politician­s, suspending a rule that has been in place since 1973.

The executive committee of the leading psychiatry group sent an email to its 3,500 members, stating they should not feel bound by a longstandi­ng rule against commenting publicly on the mental state of public figures. This also includes President Donald Trump, reported STAT news.

The former president of the associatio­n, Dr Prudence Gourguecho­n, said the email was prompted by “belief in the value of psychoanal­ytic knowledge in explaining human behaviour”.

“We don’t want to prohibit our members from using their knowledge responsibl­y... That responsibi­lity is especially great today since Trump’s behaviour is so different from anything we’ve seen before,” she said.

The Goldwater rule of 1964 keeps experts from publicly talking about the psychiatri­c condition of public figures.

It was written after a survey of more than 1,000 psychiatri­sts claimed then Republican presidenti­al nominee Barry Goldwater was “psychologi­cally unfit to be President”.

The American Psychoanal­ytic Associatio­n adopted the rule in 1972, reasoning that a psychiatri­st has to actually examine a patient in order to diagnose mental health disorders.

According to STAT there are no real consequenc­es for violating the Goldwater rule.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from India