Accounts posting on Valley conflict get Twitter warning
Microblogging site threatens users of action for violating Indian laws
Several Kashmiri Twitter users who frequently post about the Valley’s conflict claimed to have received an email from the microblogging site on Saturday saying that an “official correspondence” was received about the content on these profiles violating “Indian law”.
The email – the language of each being the same except the name of the profile – says that, “…Twitter has received official correspondence regarding your Twitter account”. The email came from Twitter’s legal department, holding the email-ID “twitter-legal@twitter.com”.
It continues, “The correspondence claims that your account is in violation of Indian law. Please note we may be obligated to take action regarding the content identified in the complaint in the future. Please let us know by replying to this email as soon as possible if you decide to voluntarily remove the content identified on your account.”
But the emails do not point to any particular post that has attracted the complaint nor clarify what exactly is the nature of the “official correspondence”.
The mail, however, says the recipient “may wish to consult legal counsel about this matter”.
Hindustan Times could confirm at least a dozen profiles have received such mails – including non-Kashmiris, like Pakistani journalist Sabena Siddiqi. She posted the notice on Twitter and asked how she, being a Pakistani citizen, could be breaking Indian laws.
A scrutiny of the profiles that have received the communication shows that some of the content they post take a separatist stand on Kashmir and question the role of India in the Valley.
Responding to an emailed query from HT, Twitter said that it doesn’t comment “on individual accounts for privacy and security reasons”.
The response however, pointed to Twitter’s “Country Withheld Content policy” which elaborates that: “Many countries have laws that may apply to Tweets and/or Twitter account content. In our continuing effort to make our services available to users everywhere, if we receive a valid and properly scoped request from an authorised entity, it may be necessary to reactively withhold access to certain content in a particular country from time to time.”
Twitter also pointed to “Lumen Database” – an international database that collects and analyses legal complaints and requests for removal of online materials – and for reference, shared the link on the database to a complaint by the ministry of electronics and information technology, dated August 24, which asks Twitter to block 115 handles for “propagating objectionable contents”.
A PDF copy of the communication is available on the database. A scroll down the attached PDF of Annexure 1 (which the government complaint refers to) lists the links to the 115 “objectionable” tweets and accounts. Some of the profiles on the list are those which HT has verified about receiving the mail.
A Kashmiri user who received the mail said, “It’s the face of India’s 21st century repression of Kashmiri activists. Since social media amplified Kashmiri voices to the world, it became a problem for the state.”