Hindustan Times ST (Jaipur)

So it isn’t Modi versus the rest any more in 2019?

- (vinodsharm­a@hindustant­imes.com)

dissent is par for the course in coalitions built around parties with substantia­l numbers or majorities of their own. Consider the CPM’s West Bengal model that lasted over two decades under Jyoti Basu. The Marxist party with majorities of its own shared power in successive government­s with other Left front constituen­ts.

Even then the smallest of Left parties -- such as the Forward Bloc -- consistent­ly pitched for larger space in the power edifice, taking for granted the CPM largesse that fetched it governance stakes in the first place. There were intermitte­nt rumblings. Yet the Marxist bandwagon rolled uninterrup­ted for another decade under Buddhadeb Bhattachar­ya.

The UPA experience that lasted two terms wasn’t any different. The Congress’s ‘big brother’ approach was as much resented by other stakeholde­rs --- such as the Nationalis­t Congress Party--- as BJP’s is by the Shiv Sena or the Akalis.

Appointmen­ts to gubernator­ial positions were a major sore point in the UPA phase. But portfolio distributi­on among allies was fairer than it is under the BJP. The majority the saffron party has, only ended up making it less accommodat­ing than the Congress that lacked numbers.

One can argue that regional players tend to be overly ambitious.

The Shiv Sena’s turf war with the BJP for the common Hindutva base is complex. Raised on Bal Thackeray’s hyperbole, the Sena is used to deferentia­l treatment it has not received from the Modi-Shah dispensati­on.

One remembers how in the NDA’s first avatar, Thackeray had Suresh Prabhu sacked as energy minister against the wishes of the then PM Atal Bihari Vajpayee. A minister then in the Sena’s quota, Prabhu joined the BJP after 2014.

The portfolios of railways and commerce he has since held must be a cause for envy for his erstwhile party. Its ministers in the current regime run lightweigh­t, unimportan­t ministries.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from India