Can’t force wife to leave India, HC tells Afghan
The Delhi high court has declined the plea of an Afghan national to direct his wife and their two children, who have obtained refugee status in India, to return with him, after the three expressed their unwillingness to live with him.
The court also denied the man visitation rig- hts to meet his children whenever he comes to India after noting that the two, aged nine and four years, have expres- sed their reluctance to meet him.
A bench of Justices S. Muralidhar and Vinod Goel noted that the man’s wife has obtained refugee status for herself and the two children under the mandate of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees ( UNHCR) and their refugee ID cards are val- id till April 12 next year.
The court said the- re was nothing on record to indicate any threat to the safety and security of the children or that they were in inconvenie- nce or their overall deve- lopment harmed during their stay in India.
“Consequently, the court has no hesitation as far as the present petition is concerned in declining the relief sou- ght for by the petitioner,” the bench said, wh- ile dismissing the man’s plea. His counsel also sought an order regarding visitation rights to the father whenever he visits India. However, as the children were not inclined to meet him, the bench said it was not possible at this stage to issue any ominous order regarding his visitation rights.
and that he may seek the relief in other appropriate proceedings available to him under the law. In pursuance to the court’s earlier order, the children had met their father at the high court’s mediation centre. The court noted that the children were reluctant to meet their father and even his wife was unwilling to return with him. According to the plea of the Afghan national, he married the woman in 2008 in Kabul and two sons were born to them in 2009 and 2014.
All of them had come to India on a tourist visa on February 18, 2017 and were staying in Kalkaji in South Delhi at a close friend’s residence, the petition said.