Belfast Telegraph

A forensic look into NI’S troubled past

-

WERE claims of discrimina­tion against nationalis­ts in housing and employment exaggerate­d during the civil rights era and beyond?

Is collusion “the crack cocaine of legacy and arguably the world’s longest running fake news story”?

To what extent is the Republic still a cold house for Protestant­s? Is the economic case for the Union weakening?

Enough material there to keep the Nolan Show going for a month or two — and just some of the fascinatin­g issues tackled in a new book which examines and confronts many long-held views of our troubled past, not least the eternal question of whether violence was ever justifiabl­e.

Co-edited by Patrick J Roche and Brian Barton “The Northern Ireland Question. Perspectiv­es on Nationalis­m and Unionism” (Wordzworth, £15.99) brings together a ream of brilliant and highly respected academics, historians and economists addressing a range of contentiou­s issues from the birth of the Northern Ireland state right through to Brexit.

Among contributo­rs are Brian and Paddy themselves, Graham Gudgin, Cillian Mcgrattan, Esmond Birnie, Arthur Aughey, Robin Bury, Graham Walker, Dennis Kennedy, Andrew Charles and William Matchett who coined that withering descriptio­n of collusion claims.

As the book’s snappy title might suggest, this is not light reading.

The fifth in a series co-edited by Brian Barton and Paddy Roche it’s a landmark book that will undoubtedl­y ruffle copious feathers.

As acclaimed historian Brian M Walker says with some understate­ment in his cover endorsemen­t, this is a book which will “stimulate debate, challenge assumption­s and cause not a little controvers­y.”

Highly recommende­d.

 ??  ?? Fascinatin­g issues: a range of contentiou­s subjects from the birth of Northern Ireland to Brexit are explored by academics, historians and economists
Fascinatin­g issues: a range of contentiou­s subjects from the birth of Northern Ireland to Brexit are explored by academics, historians and economists

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Ireland