BMW settles batch of cases over f law claims

BMW has settled a civil action in a batch of cases brought over an alleged defect that caused some of its cars to suddenly lose power and stop.

Three of the cases were before Dublin District Court last year where the manufacturer was accused of negligence by motorists who bought different models of 2008-reg BMWs, all of which are alleged to have experienced timing chain failures.

More than 50 similar actions were in the offing against BMW, Dublin District Court heard last December.

An action by John McConville from Canal View, Clones Road, Monaghan Town, Co. Monaghan was listed again yesterday. Mr McConville was among the group of motorists who initiated civil proceedings against the motor firm for €8,700 in damages.

He claimed that in 2011, significant damage was caused to his 2008-reg BMW X5-series car – which he had bought for €42,000 – when driving from Limerick to Dublin. He claimed the vehicle suddenly lost power and he had to take emergency measures.

He said a defective engine design had prevented inspection and maintenance of the timing chain and that his car needed extensive repairs.

In July, BMW Automotive (Ireland) Ltd was ordered to hand over evidence by Dublin District Court after the action brought by the three motorists.

John O’Regan, counsel BMW Ireland, told Judge John Brennan there was ongoing disclosure and an affidavit has to be sworn by his client.

He said Mr McConville’s could be put back for mention to a later date but a separate case brought by another plaintiff had been settled.

Another of the three cases was withdrawn last month.

Judge Brennan adjourned Mr McConville’s case until November 15 next.