Abortion issue can’t be debated in soundbites

MOST of us have learned to be cautious about people who maintain they are absolutely right; the more vehement they are in pressing their case, the more suspicious we might become. Not much in this world is black and white and that is why debate is crucial on life’s complexities. And nothing is more complex or contentious than the subject of abortion.

That is why remarks made by Minister for Health Simon Harris – that the issue has been debated “ad nauseam” in the Citizens Assembly and Dáil – are so ill-judged.

Rushing the campaign is unlikely to bring any more clarity and Mr Harris ought to know better.

This is a multi-faceted issue and to suggest it can be dealt with in easy soundbites is disingenuous.

The Government’s position is that abortion already exists in Ireland but is unsafe, unregulated and unlawful. The Taoiseach has said “we cannot export our problems and import our solutions”.

But the notion that everyone is agreed on how to handle crisis pregnancy is wildly simplistic.

The Cabinet has agreed to repeal the Eighth Amendment and allow enabling legislation. Yet there is a massive divergence in viewpoints on that legislation; most especially on termination up to 12 weeks. Respectful debate is absolutely essential, irrespective of voting intentions.

It is understood the 36th Amendment of the Constitution Bill 2018, enabling the referendum, will be published today. It will then be discussed in the Dáil after Cabinet approval.

A time for measured, considered discussion is in all our interest. And the advice of Desmond Tutu might also be kept in mind: “Don’t raise your voice, improve your argument.”