Irish Independent

Government must act on mandate

-

■ The Irish people gave the Government a clear mandate to legislate for abortion provision and care in their own country.

It is important that this provision is legislated in a way that does not prevent Irish women from accessing abortion.

In Italy, conscienti­ous objection means that 90pc of gynaecolog­ists in some southern regions do not provide abortion care, making abortion in these areas near impossible to access.

While conscienti­ous objection is of course a right, the Government here

should beware of unintended consequenc­es.

For example, a register of conscienti­ous objectors, while seeming a good idea at the outset, can severely limit provision.

The ethos of Catholic-run hospitals may bring pressure on doctors to place themselves on the register, effectivel­y excluding whole institutio­ns (and consultant­s associated with them) from providing abortion services. Similarly, direct or indirect pressure may be brought within practices or small peer groups in specific geographic­al areas.

Far better to respect the individual right of conscienti­ous objection, coupled with a legal duty of prompt referral, which also protects the rights of the patient.

Prompt referral is key to any conscienti­ous objection provision in the legislatio­n, and is already part of the Irish medical council guidelines.

Similarly, a register of practition­ers providing abortion care can make these practition­ers a target of anti-abortion organisati­ons. Even with exclusion zones, which are likely to be part of legislatio­n, attracting trouble is never good for women seeking care in a crisis, or for the doctors providing that care.

There is already a rising chorus of voices that seeks to water down provision on spurious cost or resource grounds.

It is important that the Government stands firm and uses the mandate given to it by two-thirds of the voters in Ireland to provide accessible, affordable abortion and reproducti­ve care to all women who need it.

Chryssa Dislis Co Cork

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Ireland