Rob Merrick
‘You voted for them’ — Barnier mocks Tory MP’s whine about EU demands
MICHEL Barnier has mocked a Tory MP’s protests about the EU’s aims for a post-Brexit trade deal — pointing out that the MP actually voted for the measures himself.
Tory ‘hardliner’ Mark Francois, head of the European Research Group, wrote to the EU’s chief negotiator last month, insisting he must drop his “unreasonable demands”.
In a scathing response, Mr Barnier sets out how those “demands” — on adherence to EU rules and the role of the European Court of Justice — were “agreed” by Boris Johnson in the Brexit deal.
It was then “voted for by the House of Commons — including yourself — as part of the withdrawal agreement ratification”, he pointed out.
In a letter dripping in sarcasm, Mr Barnier added: “All we are asking of the UK is to honour its commitments in the political declaration.” An agreement is still possible, he argues “despite the short time available, which is the choice of your government”.
The last point is a reference to Boris Johnson’s decision to reject an extension to the transition period, threatening both sides with a no-deal Brexit on December 31.
The negotiations remain deadlocked over the flashpoints listed by Mr Barnier, plus fishing rights, the UK insisting that to concede would mean giving up its sovereignty. However, the EU can point to the terms of the political declaration, signed in haste by Johnson last autumn to strike an exit deal and take the UK out of the bloc on January 31.
It agrees that, on any dispute over EU law, “the arbitration panel should refer the question to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) as the sole arbiter of Union law, for a binding ruling”. And, on so-called ‘level playing field’ issues, both sides pledged to “uphold the common high standards applicable in the Union and the United Kingdom at the end of the transition period in the areas of state aid, competition, social and employment standards, environment, climate change, and relevant tax matters”.
Despite Mr Johnson’s signature on this document, and its ratification by the Commons, the UK has insisted it will not sign a trade deal that prevents it breaking free of EU rules, or leaves it under the remit of the CJEU.
The clash came as the prime minister sparked accusations of putting Brexit before health by rejecting an invitation to join an EU scheme to procure a coronavirus vaccine.