GARDA GOLDEN MURDER REVIEW
Justice Minister releases first report into events surrounding the murder
REPORTS of domestic violence committed by the man who went on to murder Garda Tony Golden were not correctly logged by gardaí , according to a report released last week.
The report on the garda review of events leading up to the murder of Garda Golden in Omeath on October 11, 2015, found that gardaí did not correctly classify reports of domestic violence by Siobhan Philips against her former partner Adrian Crevan Mackin on the garda Pulse system. Garda Golden was shot and killed when he accompanied Siobhan Philips to collect her belongings from the house she had shared with Crevan Mackin at Mullach Alainn, Omeath.
Crevan Mackin also shot and seriously wounded Siobhan Philips before turning the gun on himself. The young mother, who sustained serious injuries in the incident, has now lodged a claim for damages against the Garda Commissioner, with the case listed in the High Court last week.
REPORTS of domestic violence committed by the man who went on to murder Garda Tony Golden were not correctly logged by Gardai, according to a report released last week.
The report on the garda review of events leading up to the murder of Garda Tony Golden in Omeath in October 2015 found that Gardai did not correctly classify reports of domestic violence by Ms. Siobhan Philips against her former partner Adrian Crevan Mackin on the garda PULSE system.
The review also highlighted Gda. Golden as ‘an exemplary member’ of the Garda, outlining ‘ his actions were beyond reproach.’
Garda Tony Golden was shot and killed when he accompanied Siobhan Philips as she went to collect her belongings from the house she had shared with Crevan Mackin at Mullach Alainn, Omeath.
Crevan Mackin also shot and seriously wounded Siobhan Philips before turning the gun on himself.
The review noted two incidents that could be classified as complaints to the Garda of domestic abuse and violence, one on September 6, 2015, and another on October 10, 2015.
It stated that neither incident was recorded in a manner that would comply with ‘relevant policy and HQ instructions.’
The report of the reviews findings said it was evident that a member of An Garda Síochána did not deal with the initial report to him at Dundalk garda station strictly in accordance with policy, and that there was an obligation on him to record a complaint from Siobhan Philips when she attended the station.
However, it said that ‘significant actions’ were taken by all relevant members for the purpose of addressing the issue subject of the complaints. It also found that even if the incidents had been properly recorded, it is unlikely that Garda Golden would have taken a different course of action.
Disciplinary proceedings were not being considered, but the review said the force has implemented a number of developments in respect of how it treats victims of domestic abuse.
The Minister for Justice and Equality, Charlie Flanagan laid before the Oireachtas the report setting out the outcome of the review by the Garda authorities of events leading up to the murder of Garda Tony Golden, and the shooting and serious injuries inflicted on Siobhan Phillips by her former partner Adrian Crevan Mackin who then turned the gun on himself.
The Minister said that while the review highlighted the two incidents ‘were not recorded in accordance with relevant policy and procedures, it does not appear that the classification of the incidents was a causative factor in these tragic events on the night of the shootings.’
‘ The murder of Garda Tony Golden at Omeath in October 2015 was a tragic loss for his family and his colleagues. We should never forget that Garda Golden was a brave man who gave his life doing his duty as a Garda and serving his fellow citizens.’
‘I understand the review undertaken was done so with great sensitivity and involved a complex piece of work. I am appealing for continued sensitivity for those who have suffered greatly as a result of these events, especially the widow and children of Garda Golden and his wider family and Ms. Phillips and her family members. My deepest sympathies are with them.’
The Minister added: ‘ The shooting of Garda Golden and Ms. Phillips was an abhorrent crime.’
‘Ms. Phillips is a young woman who has suffered great trauma and serious injuries as a result of the events of that day.’
‘ The Golden family have lost a dearly loved husband, father, brother and son. Garda Golden died selflessly doing his duty in seeking to protect the members of the community he served.’
He said the review had identified that the actions of Garda Golden were ‘ beyond reproach.’
The Minister also indicated that, in terms of the separate review undertaken by Assistant Commissioner Eugene Corcoran, ‘it is important to note that certain allegations in respect of the murder of Garda Golden are currently being examined by GSOC in two investigations.’ These investigations have been ongoing since April 2017.
The GSOC investigation was launched after an RTE Primetime programme raised questions about the dealings gardai had with Crevan Mackin after he was arrested for firearms offences and later charged with IRA membership.
He was on bail for these charges when he murdered Garda Tony Golden.
Minister Flanagan told the Oireachtas last week: ‘I have been assured by GSOC that the publication of this report will not have any adverse impact on the independent investigations underway and we should not prejudge the outcome of those investigations.’
The Minister stated: ‘Conscious of the gravity of this matter and the concerns expressed by the family of Ms. Siobhan Phillips, as well as by local public representatives, I took decision in the public interest to publish this report. The report is subject to a number of minor redactions for necessary legal and security reasons.
In responding to concerns relating to the recording and classification of crime statistics the Minister stated: ‘ Ensuring that we have robust crime data is a very important element in effectively preventing and responding to all forms of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence. ‘As the CSO have stated, there is ongoing engagement between it, An Garda Síochána and other crime statistics users, including my Department and the Policing Authority, in relation to the issues that need to be resolved to ensure our crime data is robust and corresponds to international best practice.’
The Minister further noted the recent measures being taken which are designed to improve the manner in which An Garda Síochána deals with victims of domestic abuse and welcomed the increased focus by An Garda Síochána on vulnerable victims of crimes against the person, including where the incidents of criminality occur in a domestic setting.
He added: ‘ Tackling domestic violence is an essential priority for the Government. New legislation strengthening protections for victims is currently before the Oireachtas and a multimillion euro domestic violence awareness campaign is underway.’
‘I welcome the measures taken by An Garda Síochána to improve their responses to domestic violence cases and in particular I welcome the introduction of the ‘ Revised Policy of An Garda Síochána on Domestic Violence Intervention’.
Minister Flanagan added: ‘Important progress has been made in recent years including the establishment of the Garda National Protective Services Bureau led by a Chief Superintendent, as well as a nationwide network of Garda Victim Services Offices with dedicated staff in each of the 28 Garda Divisions.’
He explained ‘ The Bureau is tasked with improving services to victims, improving the investigation of sexual and domestic violence incidents, and identifying and managing risk.
As a further measure to ensure that victims are placed at the heart of Garda service, Divisional Protective Services Units (DPSUs) will also be established in each Garda Division.
‘ This has already been rolled out on a phased basis starting with 3 Divisions - Louth, Dublin Metropolitan Region West and Cork City. The next phase of DPSUs have provisionally been identified and will be launched in the coming months.’