Leaving Certificate candidates should make case for the grade they deserve

SIR,

Minister McHugh’s decision to provide Leaving Cert candidates with calculated grades rather than an exam is understandable against the COVID-19 background. I have a few concerns about due process for candidates and calculators, however.

Firstly, it’s regrettable that the State Examinations Commission (SEC) has washed its hands of the process when its stewardship is most needed. Secondly, it is a fundamental right of a candidate to make a case to the calculator of each subject.

Each candidate should be entitled to submit her/his own grades prediction for consideration by the school. In a short submission of about 100 words per subject, the candidate should outline why the grade is deserved. Be aware, that in this process, unlike the SEC appeal system, the candidate is not entitled to appeal the calculated grade once it goes to the Department of Education.

Thirdly, to protect the calculators, it should be made clear from the outset that any attempt at canvassing, bribery or persuasion by a third party on behalf of a candidate could result in the calculated grades been withheld and proceedings being taken against the third party. All such attempts should be recorded by school authorities.

Fourthly, because of the schooling lost to COVID-19 and the distress caused by uncertainty and indecision, every candidate should be guaranteed at least a pass grade in each subject, a minimum 30 per cent at Higher Level, 40 per cent at Ordinary/ Foundation Level. No candidate should suffer the indignity of having a fail grade recorded on her/his Certificate of Calculated Grades after an ‘Annus Horribilis.’

That is the least that this cohort of resolute and resourceful young people deserves, Sincerely,

Billy Ryle

Spa

Tralee.