“CAP unfairness is destroying the family farm model” – Chris MacManus MEP
Sinn Féin MEP says new data shows that this may be the last generation of family farms
MIDLANDS Northwest MEP Chris MacManus believes this may be the last generation of family farmers, due to increased land concentration. MacManus, speaking from Brussels commented:
“I am currently engaged in negotiations on the new CAP and during the talks I requested the Commission provide data on CAP beneficiaries by farm size. I have now received the figures and they tell a very worrying story for the future of the sector.”
“Every new CAP has been marked by the notable decline in EU farmers, between 2005 and 2015 we lost four million. This is due to small farmers being forced to abandon the land as it becomes chronically unprofitable. This land is then being purchased by the big enterprises, resulting in rapid consolidation. You can be assured that the dire economic situation these farmers face is not the case for the EU processing factories or the multinational supermarkets they sell to.”
MacManus said the inequality is there for all to see in the numbers available. “The EU 2018 figures show that almost onethird (28.2%) of land is now in the hands of just 1.3% of farmers, although given their size at over 250 hectares each it would be more appropriate to call them agricultural enterprises. Due to this control of land, they swallow 23% of direct payments. On the other hand, 48.2% of all EU farmers, who are those farming 5 hectares or less, receive just 5.5% of payments.”
“How can we stand over a system where nearly 50% of farmers combined receive less than one-quarter of what the 1.3%, representing big farmers, receive? It’s nothing short of scandalous.”
“This is of course at EU level. When it comes to the situation in Ireland, I was able to determine that only 0.3% of farmers are in the over 250 hectares range, yet they receive ten times this percentage when it comes to their slice of overall payments.”
The Midlands Northwest MEP said if decisive action isn’t taken swiftly the situation will only escalate in the coming years. “This trend is only going one way and we must do more to help those small farmers hold on and increase their share of CAP funds. This is a classic case of those that need it the least, due to economies of scale, benefit the most from EU taxpayer support.”
“I believe this distribution, which is heavily skewed towards big business, has the potential to damage the reputation of the
CAP among EU consumers, who understand the value to rural Ireland of having our network of small to medium family farms.”
The Sinn Féin MEP outlined his Party’s commitment to seeking fairness in the rebalancing of CAP. “In the negotiations, we are looking at ways to identify big enterprises, those who operate under the radar by registering for financial supports under multiple individual beneficiaries.”
“Sinn Féin is committed to seeing a rebalancing of the CAP in favour of those who depend on the payments to enjoy a reasonable standard of living, rather than those who see the funds as a small supplement to already healthy profit margins”.
THEY work well together because you can leverage one off the other very efficiently, whilst still maintaining ownership of a valuable asset. How so, I hear you say? Farmers and forest owners in the past who have planted some of their marginal land have used the income they get each year to invest back into their farm or as collateral to get a load to rent or purchase other land or farm equipment. And now we have come full circle and are seeing those who planted 30 years ago harvesting these forests and being rewarded very handsomely, tax free on their wise investment. There is a reason why the market for buying land or forests is good, just hold that thought. Here at Western Forestry Co-op, Ireland’s longest established forestry co-op, our purpose is for all that income to be retained in local farms, in your pocket and local communities.
If you have been considering forestry and were wondering what your options are, have your local co-op forester Colm call out for a free visit. What is more, did you know Forestry in Ireland is 100% grant aided for the planting and fencing works, as well as an annual payment for 15 years income tax free (up to €275/acre) and you retain your Full Basic Payment Entitlements and full Ownership of Land & Trees, as well as Tax free income on your Timber Sales (this is why people want to invest in forestry and why you should do it yourself and not sell to others). What’s more, your forest will actively store carbon every year and there may be future opportunities to be able to bring this carbon to market, as well as opportunities for wind energy, tourism, it’s a win win situation if you retain ownership yourself.
If you just renewed your GLAS contract for the year and were thinking about forestry, now is the time to submit an application, which if granted is valid for 3 years, so you will have the choice what to do with your land next year, or the year after. If you would like more information on all the different forestry options available and for a free visit from your local co-op forester, please call Colm Gilheaney on 086-2008354.
Western Forestry Co-op has been providing forestry advice and services to farmers and landowners since 1985 and are proud of our strong tradition in farm forestry. It is the ethos of the co-operative to help improve farm incomes, empower forest owners to get the best return from their forest and foster indigenous forest ownership so that all the benefits from forestry be that income, carbon sequestration, biodiversity, soil and water protection, recreation etc stay in the local communities where they belong.