American Airlines pushes back on Qatar Airways plan to buy stake
American Airlines’ chief executive said on Thursday he is not “particularly excited” about Qatar Airways’ interest in buying up to 10% of the US carrier’s shares, in a letter to employees following the state-owned Gulf airline’s overture.
The move by Qatar Airways would expand its investments in North America as Qatar is embroiled in the region’s worst diplomatic crisis in years and is locked in an airspace rights row with three other Gulf states.
Separately, American Airlines Group Inc. is already part of a push by US carriers to squeeze Qatar out of their domestic market.
Along with United Continental Holdings Inc. and Delta Air Lines, American has pressed the US government to curb US flights by Qatar Airways and rival Gulf carriers Emirates and Etihad Airways.
The US carriers charge that their Gulf rivals have received billions of dollars in unfair state subsidies, allegations the Gulf carriers deny.
In his letter, American CEO Doug Parker promised to continue American’s “full court press... to stand up to companies that are illegally subsidized by their governments.”
He also said he found Qatar Airways’ proposed investment “puzzling given our extremely public stance on the illegal subsidies that Qatar, Emirates and Etihad have all received over the years from their governments.”
Qatar Airways responded on Twitter, saying: “We are glad to see American Airlines’ CEO Doug Parker’s perspective that he agrees with Qatar Airways’ belief that American Airlines is a solid financial investment.”
The potential investment is worth at least $808 million, American said in a regulatory filing on Thursday, and would put Qatar Airways’ stake on par with Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc., which holds a 10% stake in the airline.
Shares of American Airlines rose more than 5% in pre-market trade after it disclosed the potential investment. The stock closed up 1.1%.
Qatar Airways said in a statement that it sees a “strong investment opportunity” in American and that it “intends to build a passive position in the company with no involvement in management, operations or governance.”
“Qatar Airways plans to make an initial investment of up to 4.75%. Qatar Airways will not exceed 4.75% without prior consent of the American Airlines board. Qatar Airways will make all necessary regulatory filings at the appropriate time,” it said.
American, in its filing, noted potential obstacles to Qatar’s plan, as its rules prohibit “anyone from acquiring 4.75% or more of the company’s outstanding stock without advance approval from the board.” It said it had received no request from Qatar for such approval. Further, American said, “there are foreign ownership laws that limit the total percentage of foreign voting interest to 24.9%.”
American shares cheaper than rivals
A stake in American Airlines would add to Qatar Airways’ investment portfolio. The Middle East’s second biggest airline also owns 20% of British Airways-owner International Airlines Group and 10% of South America’s LATAM.
American Airlines shares are cheaper than Delta, United and JetBlue on a forward 12-month earnings per share basis, according to Thomson Reuters data, and are the cheapest among the top eight US airlines.
Qatar Airways CEO Akbar al-Baker has said the investments were purely financial, though he has looked for opportunities to cut costs or expand service with the oneworld alliance airlines in which it owns a stake.
Qatar Airways, American Airlines, IAG’s British Airways, Iberia and LATAM are all members of the oneworld airline alliance.
British Airways and Qatar Airways have a revenue-sharing partnership between their respective hubs in Doha and London, and Qatar Airways plans to launch flights to LATAM’s base in Santiago, Chile.
“The US market is strategically important to Qatar Airways and this would strengthen their ability to feed at the US end,” independent aviation consultant John Strickland told Reuters. “However, if it does go ahead it would not give them automatic antitrust immunity. That would have to be negotiated separately.”
Qatar Airways’ desire to invest in American could be as much a political decision as financial, analysts said, as Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Egypt have closed their airspace to Qatar Airways, forcing it to cut flights to those countries and fly longer, more expensive, routes.
Those countries cut diplomatic and transport ties with Qatar earlier this month, accusing it of fomenting regional unrest, supporting terrorism and getting too close to Iran.
“There’s a good chance this investment plan by Qatar Airways may have more to do with demonstrating sovereign Qatar’s continued commitment to the United States amid the latest Gulf States feud with Qatar,” Gimme Credit analyst Vicki Bryan wrote in a research note.
Al-Baker, highly critical of the blocking of airspace, has said Qatar Airways would use the aircraft used to fly to those countries for fast-track expansion plans elsewhere. (Reuters)