Canada’s struggling energy industry takes stock at annual Stampede party
CALGARY, Alberta (Reuters) – Frustration was palpable among Canadian energy executives who flocked to the annual Calgary Stampede celebrations in Canada’s oil capital, even though a recent pipeline approval gives them something to celebrate amid the rodeo competitions, corporate parties and pancake breakfasts.
The federal government’s approval of the Trans Mountain expansion last month was a boost for the battered industry. On top of that, crude prices have stabilized, an aggressively pro-energy party has come to power in Alberta and overall production in the country is around 5 million barrels per day – making Canada the world’s fourth-largest producer.
Yet millions of barrels of crude remain in storage because of stubborn delays in pipeline expansion caused by legal challenges from environmental and indigenous groups. The transportation problems have forced the Alberta government to curtail crude production to prop up Canadian oil prices, which trade at a discount to US barrels. Foreign investment in Canada’s energy industry is down sharply, and unemployment remains stubbornly high.
All this has dampened the mood at the Stampede, the Canadian energy industry’s biggest party, a 10-day extravaganza of drinking, Western dress-up and networking.
“The unpredictability of getting pipelines built has kept capital out of Canada and it’s not getting any better,” RS Energy analyst Samir Kayande said.
Canadian energy companies rely on pipelines to get crude from the oil sands province of Alberta to markets. Canadian energy capital investment in 2019 is forecast to be C$37 billion, less than half its level of C$81b. in 2014. Many foreign oil companies have exited Canada, leaving the industry in the hands of domestic producers.
For some, this could be an opportunity – but only if market access is worked out.
“Canada is on sale. The question is whether this is a temporary sale or a permanent loss,” said Rob Dionne, vice president at fund manager Scheer Rowlett & Associates, referring to low valuations of Canadian firms.
In the Wildhorse Saloon Stampede tent, pitched on a lot downtown, the atmosphere was quieter than in past years, according to one oil trader at a corporate event on Monday, even as hundreds of revelers in cowboy hats and plaid shirts filled the dance floor.
High unemployment in the industry put a noticeable damper on festivities, the trader said, with Repsol SA the latest foreign firm to cut jobs.
Many feel if Alberta could increase market access by building more pipelines, producers could unlock billions more barrels of bitumen and boom times would return to Canada, home to the world’s third largest oil reserves.
TC Energy’s Keystone XL, Enbridge Inc’s Line 3 and the government-owned Trans Mountain expansion have been delayed for years by legal and regulatory challenges. Enbridge’s Line 5 pipeline is also facing legal challenges in Michigan over its underwater crossing in the Great Lakes.
“The really important thing in the short to medium-term is getting these development pipeline projects completed and in service,” Cenovus Energy Chief Executive Officer Alex Pourbaix said.
“If all of those projects go, this industry probably has a significant runway before we have to worry about market access again.”
The key word is “if.” One Calgary-based source at a major Canadian midstream company noted he was in junior high when Keystone XL was first proposed, so he is skeptical about Trans Mountain.
The Trans Mountain expansion will triple pipeline capacity to the Pacific coast, but supporters are braced for legal challenges after a previous government approval was overturned.
The industry is accustomed to having its hopes raised and dashed, making investors gunshy about Canada. Those who do invest focus on big oil sands companies while smaller companies get ignored, said Laura Lau, senior portfolio manager with Brompton Group.
Investors want construction to start on Trans Mountain and progress on the Royal Dutch Shell-led LNG Canada project in northern British Columbia, Lau added.
Still, the outlook for the oil sector is better now than it was in late 2018, when well-organized environmental activists helped overturn the original Trans Mountain approval and oil production outpaced pipeline capacity, pushing the discount on Canadian oil to record levels surpassing $50 a barrel.
The Alberta government curtailments helped margins for struggling local producers but until transportation improves, Canadian crude prices will be squeezed.
In Calgary there is still hope that global appetite for Canadian oil will increase at the expense of less stable jurisdictions like Venezuela, while pipelines will expand.
“Canada needs all the stars to align to get people’s attention,” Lau said. “They have been disappointed for so long.”