When culture and gospel clash
Dear Editor,
In celebration of their 65th anniversary, the Jamaica Broilers Group Limited was excited to host the Best Dressed Chicken Fun in the Son event, which was held last Saturday at National Stadium in Kingston.
The staple Christian event, which incorporates a fun day and high-spirited gospel concert, was first held in 2002 in Ocho Rios; therefore, it is around two decades old — minus the years affected by the novel coronavirus pandemic.
Since Saturday there have been ongoing debates and discussions surrounding international gospel artiste Kirk Franklin’s attire and performance. The social media court of public opinion has been roasting him immensely, cancelling him for what was considered to be inappropriate dress and dance moves. Franklin wore a tank top, jeans shorts, and a pair of sneakers. Irate Christians questioned whether he was at the gym, especially as his pronounced biceps were inescapable.
Many people have voiced their disgust and displeasure with Franklin. Some said there is a difference between a gospel performer and a gospel artiste, while others raised arguments of perversion, lust, and self-centredness. In summary, they firmly conclude that, in such a context, the Son (Jesus Christ) was not glorified.
However, for those who are true fans of Franklin, they would know that he has forever been a highly energetic performer and always does his dance moves to entertain his audience and build a certain vibe with them. But did he go too far?
Did the saints expect him to show up in a three-piece jacket suit? That would be overdressing, especially as it is a relaxed, casual event — and Jamaica is very hot! But could he have been more modest? And at the same time, doesn’t Joel 2:13, a scripture that is often used to justify dressing as one pleases, say, “Rend your hearts and not your garments...”?
Understanding cultural and subcultural practices is essential when entering other peoples’ spaces. It is also a sign of respect. As part of intercultural communicative competence, one should study the values of others so as not to cause any deliberate offence. Therefore, while Jamaica is a tropical climate, Franklin could have covered up those muscles.
Many of the people who disagreed with Franklin’s appearance are labelled judgemental and self-righteous. Some even suggested that if they were so caught up in the singer’s attire and dance moves, their hearts were not centred on the Son. However, we must understand that the overall presentation of an individual adds to the degree to which his message is accepted and interpreted.
Franklin’s presentation and performance highlight the clash between traditional and modern perspectives of Christianity. Is God only present when we sing prayer refrains and hymns? Is the Holy Spirit’s presence only felt when the entire room erupts in unknown tongues?
In any case, the organisers of Fun in the Son may want to examine the feedback about last Saturday’s show as they make plans and preparations for future stagings.
Oneil Madden maddenoniel@yahoo.com