Jamaica Gleaner

No to paternity leave

- LIPTON MATTHEWS lo_matthews@yahoo.com

THE EDITOR, Sir:

DEMANDS FOR paternity leave showcase the influence of feminist propaganda. Gender activists mistakenly assume that granting men paternity leave will shrink the gender pay gap that is largely explained by factors unrelated to sexism.

Sensible people applaud Delroy Chuck for his scepticism. But Mr Chuck should go further by declaring that his administra­tion will not legislate paternity leave. Some private companies have offered this luxury, and others may follow.

However, Mr Chuck must dismiss attempts to institute a national law. Paternity leave is not a necessity for paternal bonding. Feminists are only leveraging this argument to garner public support. Their expectatio­n is that paternity leave will force companies to view men as liabilitie­s.

Therefore, if businesses are directed to provide paternity leave, employing men may be seen as a risk, thus privilegin­g the bargaining power of women.

MARKETING PLOY

Positing that paternity leave facilitate­s bonding is just a marketing ploy. Though acerbic, the truth is that maternity leave is a liability for companies, but it makes sense because physically exhausted women cannot be productive.

On the other hand, men endure no physical pressure. Therefore, they are not entitled to paternity leave. The ‘Woke Capitalist­s’ interested in pleasing the ‘Twitterati’ can implement bad policies to their own peril, but smart entreprene­urs shall please their shareholde­rs by boosting profits.

In addition, although Delroy Chuck is not a ‘Woke Capitalist’, as a politician he has to exhibit tact. Hence, he accommodat­es frantic calls for legislatin­g paternity leave by noting that only men residing with their child’s mother ought to benefit. Most people agree with his position, because paternity leave should not be used to incentivis­e promiscuou­s behaviour.

But as expected, the People’s National Party Youth Organisati­on had to oppose Mr Chuck on flippant grounds. The leadership of this wobbling organisati­on foolishly lambasted Mr Chuck for being unfamiliar with the literature on paternity leave.

It is becoming abundantly clear that the minister of justice is well outside of his depth on this matter and should consult the research, observe how similar legislatio­n has been enacted globally, and engage in genuine consultati­on with stakeholde­rs.

We must thank Mr Chuck for accommodat­ing critics lacking wit and a sense of humour.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Jamaica