Gulf states take shine off cushy government jobs
Ahmed, a Qatari civil servant, used to arrive at his office at a government ministry in Doha late in the morning and leave for home after lunch, collecting a monthly salary of 40,000 rials ($11,000) and a generous housing and travel allowance. But last month a government official made a surprise spot check on the ministry’s offices and found dozens of employees absent. “Punctuality is a duty,” said a letter Ahmed received from the minister’s office. “Qatar expects the best of its citizens.”
For a country whose tiny population is the world’s wealthiest per capita and which sits upon its largest natural gas reserves, increasing the productivity of its 90,000 public employees might seem like a needless task. But it is part of a trend across the Gulf as economies there try to lessen the burden of costly public sectors. Gulf states have for decades used their energy wealth to provide millions of citizens with cushy government jobs, part of a social contract that rewards educational attainment with employment for life.“
But high-paying public sector jobs that demand little of workers have led to bureaucratic inertia and an absenteeism culture that governments turned a blind eye to during the Gulf’s boom years. In 2011 a Kuwait government report found that half the country’s state employees were absent from work between January and March, costing the country’s treasury more than KD 10.5 million ($35 million).
Since oil prices plunged in 2014, however, Gulf monarchies have curbed subsidies and laid off staff as they try to trim budget deficits and build economies less reliant on hydrocarbons. In the wealthier Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries of Kuwait, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates, where populations are small, more than 75 percent of employed nationals work in the public sector, according to the IMF. The ratio is also high in oil-giant Saudi Arabia - which racked up a record budget deficit of nearly $100 billion last year - while in Oman, about 50 percent of employed nationals work in the public sector. Bahrain has the lowest proportion of nationals working in the public sector, at 35 percent.
In one of the most dramatic efforts to shake government agencies out of their slumber, the ruler of Dubai, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, carried out an early morning spot check on the city state’s management in August, found empty desks, and sacked nine senior officials. Pictures of Sheikh Mohammed wandering the sparsely populated offices of the Land Department were widely published in local newspapers.
Qatar, in an apparent effort to codify the responsibilities of government employees and get them working harder, last month passed a law that raised pay for workers who have achieved higher levels of education and enforced a merit-based promotion scheme. The nation’s young emir has warned citizens that the state “can no longer provide for everything” and local newspaper editorials mock lazy civil servants referred to jokingly by Qataris as “people of the couch”. Neighboring Saudi Arabia in September scaled back financial perks for public sector employees in one of the most drastic measures yet by the oil-rich kingdom to save money at a time of low oil prices. Lured by a generous salary and his own office overlooking the Arabian Gulf, 26-year-old Ahmed, who declined to give his second name, joined Qatar’s ministry of transport last year after graduating from Qatar University. On his first day, Ahmed said, he was surprised to find colleagues without clear responsibilities carrying documents from one office to another. “Many workers, even managers, were engaged in watching television or sleeping,” he said.
One colleague advised him to get to know the “tea boys” - Nepali waiters who deliver tea to offices - so he could find out when his boss had left and do the same. Other skiving tactics included leaving a jacket on the back of his chair so a casual observer would assume he was first to arrive at the office and programming emails to send themselves in the afternoon so managers thought he was still at work. But superiors started to clamp down on those evading work, Ahmed said, after Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani, Qatar’s emir, called on Nov 1 for Qataris to move off social welfare and “into action” in the face of low energy prices.
After Arab spring protests in 2011, rich Gulf states spent billions of dollars raising salaries and investing in subsidies and infrastructure. Wars and social turmoil spurred efforts in countries like Saudi Arabia to boost employment of their citizens and crack down on illegal hiring of foreign workers. But today austerity is unnerving citizens for whom affluence and stellar growth are the norm. Reforms are proving sensitive politically consequential even - and there are fears that further cuts to sumptuous welfare states could heighten public anger.
In May oil workers in Kuwait went on strike against a proposed overhaul of the public sector payroll system. An election last month filled the country’s parliament with opposition lawmakers opposed to wage cuts and taxes. Omani medics from state-funded colleges in November held a two-week strike after their salaries were cut. Ending the legacy of public sectors being an engine of job creation, analysts say, is vital to avoid rising unemployment in years ahead if oil revenues decline again and nationals are still not working in the private sector. But Gulf youth may still expect to be entitled to a share of the national wealth whether in the form of public sector jobs with high wages or breaks from future taxes. — Reuters