Time to ditch polar bears? New climate images sought
What does climate change look like? For many people, the first - or perhaps only image that comes to mind is of smokestacks, or polar bears perched on ice floes. “If you go to Google and click on climate change images, you have to go a long way before you hit many images of people,” says Adam Corner, research director at Climate Outreach, an Oxford-based think-tank that aims to boost public engagement on climate change.
But climate change already is affecting billions of people around the world, from farmers in Zimbabwe experimenting with new crops to battle drought to grandmothers in India who earn cash selling solar home lighting systems, or children in the United States coping with a longer allergy season. Getting more of those people-focused images into the media, into NGO campaigns and into other public communications could help more people identify with the problem, see the opportunities and understand the need for action, Corner said.
“There’s nothing wrong with polar bears,” he said. “But they’re very distancing images. They identify climate change as something that happens far away where most people’s lives aren’t. They don’t do justice to the richness of the human experience of climate change.” In an effort to widen that narrow view, Corner’s organization has launched a new portal for climate change images. Inspired by Facebook executive Sheryl Sandberg’s Lean In effort - which has worked to make sure online searches for images of women offer up more than just lingerie models - the Climate Visuals portal showcases a diverse range of climate change photographs drawn from stock photo agencies.
Images so far, provided by early partners such as US-based Aurora Photos, include US homeowners installing attic insulation, women in Burkina Faso pumping scarce water, and European researchers studying the migration of grasses in the Alps. There are scientists monitoring glaciers too - but no polar bears. “The question is, if you make a change upstream in what’s available, can you politically influence the way people think about that issue?” Corner said. “Climate change has gotten stuck behind some iconic but limited images. We’re trying to kickstart a broader, more diverse visual language for it.”
Worth a Thousand Words
The not-for-profit effort is far from the first to try to reshape thinking about global warming and help people engage with what, for some, feels like an invisible and distant problem despite its clear and growing threats. But the project is one of the first to look at images, rather than language, something Corner finds surprising. “It’s very strange given we’re an increasingly visual culture,” he said. “The old adage about a picture painting a thousand words is really true - especially given attention spans.”
Before launching the portal, Corner and colleagues conducted surveys in the United States, Britain and Germany to find out what people liked - and didn’t - about photographs of climate change. What they discovered is that viewers wanted to see people dealing with or taking action on climate change - though many said they’re tired of seeing climate change protesters. However, people don’t like being made to feel guilty about their personal choices such as flying rather than taking the train, or eating steak rather than vegetables - so showing a family going on holiday on a plane as an example of what needs to change “can backfire”, Corner said.
Photographs of traffic jams or industrial-scale food waste - both contributors to climate change - “people were more able to accept as a cause of climate change and relate to”, he said. Corner hopes the new portal will attract a range of contributors and users, including media, NGOs and campaign groups. Users will be able to click on the images on the portal and be taken directly back to the agencies that supplied the photos, with the agencies handling any sales.
He is also working with World Press Photo to try to establish a new award category for climate change photographs in next year’s competition another way to encourage thinking about a broader range of climate images beyond polar bears and smokestacks. “The question is, what would happen if you don’t get just that narrow range of images?” he asked. “Do people go clicking for polar bears? Or would they be happy to find a more diverse range of human stories something they can relate to?”