100 years on, influenza holds lessons for next pandemic
World remains ill-prepared for the next global killer
PARIS: It was the disease to end all others, infecting a third of humanity, killing tens of millions in their beds and prompting panicked talk of the end of days across continents still reeling from war. One hundred years on from the influenza outbreak known as the Spanish Flu, scientists say that while lessons have been learned from the deadliest pandemic in history, the world is ill-prepared for the next global killer.
In particular, they warn that shifting demographics, antibiotic resistance and climate change could all complicate any future outbreak. “We now face new challenges including an ageing population, people living with underlying diseases including obesity and diabetes,” University of Melbourne Dr Carolien van de Sandt, at the Peter Doherty Institute for Infection and Immunity, told AFP yesterday.
Scientists predict that the next influenza pandemicmost likely to be a strain of bird flu that infects humans and spreads rapidly across the world via air travel-could kill up to 150 million people. Van de Sandt and her team examined reams of data on the Spanish Flu, which tore across the planet in 1918. They also studied three further pandemics: the 1957 “Asian” flu, the “Hong Kong” flu of 1968 and 2009’s swine flu outbreak.
They found that although the Spanish Flu infected one in three people, many patients managed to survive severe infection and others displayed only mild symptoms. Unlike most nations, which used war-time censorship to supress news of the spreading virus, Spain remained neutral during World War I. Numerous reports of the sickness in Spanish media led many to assume the disease originated there and the name stuck.
It is now largely believed that the strain of flu in 1918 in fact originated among US servicemen and killed a disproportionately high amount of soldiers and young people, but researchers said things would be different this time around. In 1918, in a world struggling with the economic impact of global war, the virus was rendered deadlier due to high rates of malnutrition.
But the team behind a new study, published in the Journal Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology, said the next outbreak will spread in the developed world among a population struggling with record obesity and diabetes rates.
Double burden
“What we know from the 2009 pandemic is that people with certain diseases (such as obesity and diabetes) were significantly more likely to be hospitalized with, and die from, influenza,” Kirsty Short, from the school of Chemistry and Biosciences at the University of Queensland, said. The team warned that the world faced a “double burden” of severe disease due to widespread malnutrition in poor nations-exacerbated by climate changeand over nutrition in richer ones. And global warming could impact in other ways.
Van de Sandt said that since many influenza strains begin in birds, a heating planet could alter where the next outbreak emerges. “Climate change may change migration patterns of birds, bringing potential pandemic viruses to new locations and potentially a wider range of bird species,” she said. One thing the investigation into 1918 threw up was that older people fared significantly better against the virus strain than younger adults. The team theorized that this was due in part due to older citizens having built up some immunity through previous infections.
Most of those killed in 1918 — roughly 50 million people, or 2.5 percent of those infected-died due to secondary bacterial infections, something that antibiotics helped alleviate during subsequent pandemics. But today many bacteria are immune to antibiotics. “This increases the risk that people again will suffer from and die as a result of secondary bacterial infections during the next pandemic outbreak,” said Katherine Kedzierska, from Melbourne’s Doherty Institute.
The authors sounded particular alarm over avian H7N9 — a virus that kills roughly 40 percent of people it infects, even if it cannot currently pass from human to human. “At the moment none of these viruses has acquired the ability to spread between humans, but we know that the virus only needs to make a few minor changes to make this happen and could create a new influenza pandemic,” said van de Sandt.
Global warming could impact in other ways