‘#MeToo has a chilling effect on camaraderie’
A LOBBYIST flies solo from Texas to Washington to press his case on the Hill, leaving behind the female associate who did much of the work on the issue.
He recognises that his decision to fly alone is a lost opportunity for his talented young co-worker, but right now, with everything that’s going on, he’s not willing to risk a business trip alone with a woman - even if what he sees as caution strikes many women as discrimination.
As a wave of sexual misconduct allegations against prominent men crested in recent months, relations between men and women in workplaces across the country have shifted - sometimes toward more honest discussions of what’s not OK at work, but also toward silence and exclusion, a quiet backlash against the righteous pride of the # MeToo movement.
In Chicago, police technician Kathern Caldwell sees blank stares on men when the topic of sexual misconduct comes up and worries that “men on the job are thinking, what’s wrong with us women?”
In Sacramento, California, a union leader struggles over how to handle the man who calls her several times a day “to ask questions that aren’t really even questions, you know what I mean?”
“I know what to do if somebody touches me and says something awful to me, but the subtle things are almost worse because you can’t control it,” said Joyce Thomas-Villaronga, president of the local United Auto Workers chapter. She reported her fears to a supervisor and stopped answering the man’s calls. He, in turn, complained about her being unresponsive. “People are finding their way in a new system,” she said.
In Silicon Valley, the chief executive of a midsize company asked his human resources manager what he should do about the undercurrent of tension around issues of sexual misconduct. Stop having dinners with female employees, he was advised. In fact, stop having dinners with any employees. Lunches are OK, dinners no way, HR told him.
Another investor said his colleagues have cancelled their one- on- one meetings with female entrepreneurs. And some men have taken to comparing their own new approach to that of Vice President Mike Pence, who has said that he does not dine alone with any woman but his wife.
“My research over the past couple of years showed that men were hesitant to have one- onone meetings, go out to lunch or go on business trips alone with a woman,” said Kim Elsesser, a psychologist at the University of California at Los Angeles and author of “Sex and the Office.” “Now it’s gotten worse. We need to educate everyone in the workplace not only about what not to do, but that going out to lunch is important - if you segregate by gender, that’s discrimination.”
But the # MeToo movement will fail if it focuses on “legalistic solutions rather than practical ones,” said Johnny Taylor, president of the Society for Human Resource Management, which has 285,000 members in the HR field.
In recent weeks, Taylor said, chief executives of “several major companies have told us they are now limiting travel between the genders,” telling men, for example, that they may no longer take female colleagues on business trips or share rental cars with women. “That’s legalistic and not realistic,” Taylor said. “I told one CEO, ‘How does that prevent male- onmale relationships?’ It’s really impractical. We need to change the culture, not create rules that people will ignore.”
Although most of the national discussion about sexual misconduct has focused on a few highly public industries - mainly Hollywood, media and politics - those high-profi le cases have sparked conversations and change in factories, offices and wherever people spend their workdays.
As their fi re engine heads back to Station 501 after an intense call, Lt. Eric Pena and his fellow fi refighters in Manchaca, Texas, debrief on what they’ve just seen - and trade coarse banter to ease the stress.
“Oh man, you looked scared; you looked like a little bitch,” one of the guys will say. A rookie will get teased as “just a virgin.” It’s “all fun and games,” a way to cope with the job’s daily traumas, Pena said.
But with the news about sexual harassment lately, Pena’s been thinking twice about who else is present when the jokes fly. Though all the fi refighters are men, Pena said female medics are sometimes around.
“We have to make our own judgment, ‘Hey, is it OK to talk the way you talk to your crew when there are other people around and you’re not really sure how their personality is?’ “said Pena, 40. The men on his shift “understand that if there’s someone new in the room . . . hey, we gotta watch our mouth.”
At Michael Teixido’s otolaryngology practice in Wilmington, Delaware, the annual holiday party has long featured a joke video lampooning the doctors. Using animated templates from the JibJab comedy website, they’d paste the heads of their colleagues onto a “Rocky Horror Picture Show” scene or a Cossack dance line. This year, his colleagues voted to scrap one that was going to feature the physicians’ faces on Chippendale dancer bodies. No one had complained, but the mood had changed.
“We’re defi nitely in a period of heightened awareness,” said Teixido, who welcomes the new thoughtfulness even as he laments missing a chance to let the staff laugh at the bosses. “There’s a real shift occurring in the trenches of life.”
Change has come for both women and men, as women feel emboldened to speak out against inappropriate behaviour, and men think twice about what’s acceptable at work.
In discussions across the country, Taylor, the HR executive, said he found that “every man I’ve spoken to is afraid. They really don’t know what to do. I read a list of things millennial women don’t want to see anymore, like opening doors for them or pulling out chairs. So if a group of us go out, how do I know if this woman likes the chivalry of opening a door and this other woman doesn’t?”
Tracy Wilson sees the caution and confusion every day as general manager of the Red Velvet and Bakers & Baristas bakeries in the District. “A lot of males are definitely feeling more self conscious, acting more guarded ,” she said. “It’s a shift. The critical mass has been reached.”
That pivot has made work life both easier and harder, Wilson said: When a female employee confided recently that she’d been the victim of a sexual assault, “I was grateful that she felt she could talk about it now because of everything that’s been going on.”
But Wilson has also seen people pull back from once- casual and harmless behaviours. In many workplaces, that comes down to awkward decisions about, of all things, hugs.
Wilson’s husband, who travels a lot for work, used to hug colleagues he hadn’t seen in a while, but now, she said, “there’s a cautiousness you have to have. You don’t want your personality to be construed the wrong way, so you pull back on that hug. The pendulum has swung the opposite way, maybe too much. We’re all going to be walking on eggshells for a while.”
Pena, the fire fighter, has what he calls “a hugging relationship” with a female medic on his shift, and he’s confident that nothing has changed in their worksibling connection, so he’s still hugging.
But when a beloved colleague walked into an office training session on Monday, ThomasVillaronga, the union official, stepped toward the young man she had mentored and stopped herself from embracing him as she normally would. Instead, she stuck out her hand.
She wasn’t worried about his reaction so much as the crowd of people around them. A toofriendly greeting seemed to carry more risk than it used to.
“I typically don’t think about those things, but now you have to step back,” she said. “What’s happening is good, but it is having a chilling effect on camaraderie. I think this is going to be the new normal.”
My research over the past couple of years showed that men were hesitant to have one-on-one meetings, go out to lunch or go on business trips alone with a woman,. Now it’s gotten worse. We need to educate everyone in the workplace not only about what not to do, but that going out to lunch is important - if you segregate by gender, that’s discrimination. Kim Elsesser, psychologist