Govt refutes claims of oppressing refugees, foreign detainees
As of March 7, the number of individuals housed in them is 13,655 which is clearly under capacity.
Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail
KUALA LUMPUR: The Ministry of Home Affairs has refuted allegations in the latest Human Rights Watch (HRW) report, which claimed that the government oppressed refugee groups and foreign nationals by placing them in overcrowded detention centres allegedly exceeding capacity.
Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail said there are currently 20 immigration depots nationwide with a capacity of 20,650.
“As of March 7, the number of individuals housed in them is 13,655 which is clearly under capacity.
“The HRW report stands dismissed on its own merits. Let the figures speak for themselves. Is it overcrowded? The answer is no.
“How much do we spend to manage these 20 depots? Last year, we allocated RM123 million but spent only RM83 million,” Saifuddin explained.
Elaborating during the Minister’s Question Time in the Dewan Rakyat yesterday in response to Lim Guan Eng (PHBagan), he said when individuals are deported, the government even covers their ferry and air travel expenses.
“However, HRW claims that we engage in torture leading to fatalities,” he added.
Saifuddin further noted that the occupants of immigration depots primarily hail from Myanmar with a total of 4,541 individuals, followed by Indonesia (3,797), Philippines (2,914), Bangladesh (1,000), Thailand (329), and 1,054 from various other countries.
He highlighted that those held in immigration depots consist of individuals who have completed prison sentences for numerous offenses and are awaiting travel documents, as well as those apprehended under various offences under the Immigration Act and passport-related laws.
“There are even UNHCR cardholders among the detainees, but they include individuals involved in legal violations, drugrelated crimes, rape, murder, and rare earth theft cases in Sik, Kedah,” he said, adding that a total of 41,658 individuals were repatriated to their respective countries last year.
Following the release of the HRW report, the Parliamentary Select Committee had called upon the Ministry of Home Affairs and relevant nongovernmental organisations to present clarifications regarding the issue, he stated.
“However, it is understood that when HRW was requested to provide evidence supporting their claims, including specifying the locations of alleged deaths and oppression, they were unable to do so.
“They could not present a shred of evidence, yet they have broadcast their report worldwide,” he said.
Saifuddin announced that the ministry would dispatch a letter urging HRW to provide evidence and explain the “profoundly irresponsible allegations”.
Additionally, he conveyed appreciation to the Parliamentary Select Committee for granting the Immigration Department the opportunity to present a rebuttal.
“We are committed to cooperating, hoping that a more credible version from us can be disseminated to neutralise all these accusations. We are a country that strictly adheres to the law, taking actions based on compassion and humanity,” he affirmed.
Moreover, he underscored the ongoing collaboration with UNHCR, emphasising the Ministry of Home Affairs’ steadfast commitment to providing support whenever the commission seeks assistance, including verifying individuals’ identities in detention centres.
He observed that presently, UNHCR has documented the registration of 189,000 refugees in the country, in contrast to the records maintained by the ministry which contains 40,000 individuals.