Hitting the pocket of traffickers
To fight wildlife crime, experts say ’follow the money’.
BANGkok: In most cases, the conviction of a Thai man trafficking rhino horns through a bizarre scheme that involved hiring prostitutes to pose as trophy hunters would have marked the end of the story.
But investigators took an unusual, next step – deciding to “follow the money” that helped bankroll the South African operation. That led to a court order last year to seize Chumlong Lemtongthai’s Thai bank accounts and other assets, including a house worth US$ 142,000 (RM594,625), to shut him down.
It was one of an increasing number of cases illustrating how nations are shifting tactics in fighting a global wildlife trafficking market worth up to US$23bil (RM96bil), after decades of relying on headline-grabbing police raids that have had little overall effect in halting illicit trades.
The idea is “to pick the pocket of the wildlife traffickers and try to freeze them in their tracks”, said Steve Galster, founder of the antitrafficking Freeland Foundation.
The approach is quickly becoming mainstream.
The UN General Assembly this week urged the world’s nations to adopt laws that allow wildlife crimes to be investigated as potential money-laundering crimes.
That allows law enforcement agents to use actions against traffickers such as seizing assets, monitoring of financial transactions and red-flagging suspicious accounts or individuals.
With crime gangs increasingly turning to wildlife smuggling as a lucrative trade, experts say customs agents and police need to begin adopting these tools commonly used to fight drug lords and other crime kingpins.
“We’ve gone beyond kicking down the door and looking for animals in the back room, to looking at who’s the kingpin, who’s the transportation coordinator, who ultimately is the vulnerable node in the syndicate without whom the syndicate wouldn’t work,” said Galster.
A new report this week calls this effort “urgent”, given how quickly crime gangs are evolving.
Agencies fighting wildlife crime need to conduct financial investigations after every bust – to identify broader crime networks and uncover criminal proceeds that can be frozen or confiscated, says the report by the Royal United Services Institute, a British think tank.
Suspicious transactions and bank clients can be “red flagged” for agencies, including financial intelligence units, to monitor and investigate, it says. Watch lists of alleged poachers can be shared.
“We’ve been very slow to recognise wildlife crime as serious transnational organised crime,” said Cathy Haenlein, one of the report’s authors.
The trafficking epidemic has surged in recent years as incomes in Asia have risen.
Tonnes of carved ivory, ivory tusks, rhino horns, live pangolins and pangolin scales have been seized in just the last few months in Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam and Indonesia.
But most arrests still only involve low-level smugglers.
For too long, Haenlein said, nations saw wildlife trafficking as an issue for conservationists. That’s allowed traffickers to flourish – using crypto-currency markets to make illicit bulk trades, or stockpiling durable animal parts like pangolin scales or elephant tusks in an attempt to corner the market.
That gives traffickers perverse incentive to drive down a species’ population so that the value of their stockpile goes up even further.
But international investigators and countries’ crime units are catching on.
Now, “it’s very clear that it is about the money”, Haenlein said.
Focusing investigations on the connections between poachers, smugglers and those financing the operations “could have the potential to change the game”.
Interpol recently said it was now going after high-profile Asian traffickers sourcing wildlife from Africa with help from anti-corruption crime units and digital forensics, to extract data from seized electronic equipment.
Some investigators are tracking sea shipments in an attempt to identify who is booking suspicious cargo transports around the globe.
“A large seizure often has interesting facts around it,” said Julian Newman of the Environmental Investigation Agency.
“Money has been moved somewhere to book a container (for the smuggled goods).”
Only by following the money will investigators track down the kingpins and financiers, who “never touch the stuff, they handle it through proxies”, Newman said.