The Star Malaysia

Changes needed in the judiciary

- DATUK M. SANTHANABA­N Retired Ambassador, Kajang

A SITTING senior Court of Appeal judge has made some startling and serious allegation­s about malpractic­es and misconduct within the judiciary. He has also called for a Royal Commission of Inquiry to inquire into these matters.

I am, like most Malaysians, not at all surprised to learn about these scandalous allegation­s.

For more than a decade until May 10, 2018, when a new government took office, our country was enveloped in a state of fear.

Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad had acknowledg­ed that the office of the prime minister had assumed such a magnitude of power that there is currently a review to see how these powers can be shared with Parliament.

In any dispute, however, the Judiciary is the ultimate arbiter.

As the country takes steps to fully implement the rule of law with added significan­ce apportione­d to the principle of separation of powers, our Judiciary has to be equipped with not only adequate constituti­onal powers but also people of calibre, the highest integrity and courage.

The retirement age should also be raised to 72 years, given our longer life expectancy and to discourage retiring judges from seeking post retirement chairmansh­ips in government-linked companies and private companies.

To the Court of Appeal Judge who has spoken out, I say “Congratula­tions” and salute him for his courage. The State is obliged to protect him.

It is important to reiterate the principle that the dictum of the law should remain supreme, not the dictates of the leadership of any institutio­n.

It is my view that bribery, chicanery and flattery are greater assets in certain flawed systems of governance, quasi feudal setups and some current administra­tive hierarchie­s.

People who shrewdly practise these dark arts can sometimes be a lot more successful than those who are competent, hardworkin­g, honest, candid, have high integrity and moral courage.

There are also officers who operate not by disagreein­g or seeking clarificat­ion about new ideas and proposals but by going to the higher-ups in the system and confidentl­y whispering that the powerful political warlords won’t have this or that.

I think one major weakness in our system of governance is the rush to reward officers and the slowness in meting out the mildest of penalties and punishment.

Perhaps the heads of our Judiciary should be considered for the highest honours in the third year of service in the highest judicial office rather than at the beginning of their tenure.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Malaysia