Treaty document left on train
Iwi in settlement negotiations circumspect over staffer’s error.
Anegotiator lost a confidential document about a Treaty of Waitangi settlement while taking a train to work.
Emails released to the Herald on Sunday by the Ministry of Justice show after the loss was reported, officials discussed how to best break the bad news to the iwi involved.
Tension eased when a response came back: “Sh*t happens.”
The Office of Treaty Settlements was in confidential talks with an iwi in May 2016 when a negotiator took home a report on the proposed multimillion-dollar settlement.
They had the 12-page document on the 8am train from Naenae to central Wellington the next morning, but during the short walk to the Ministry of Justice office realised it was gone.
After checking their bag, the negotiator retraced their steps to the station and arrived to see the empty train pulling away.
Nothing was handed to lost - and found and, back at the office, a privacy incident notification form was completed.
That set off an email chain. One official advised phoning the iwi to confess and apologise, covering points including that the lost document “contains information about quantum, negotiations etc”.
In case of media interest, a statement would be given acknowledging the breach should not have happened and making clear the employee at fault had been spoken to.
Phone calls were made. Early that May 18, 2016 evening, the Office of Treaty Settlements deputy director emailed an update on how the bad news had been received — philosophically, it turned out.
“Their response was, ‘sh*t happens’,” the ministry official wrote. “They are okay.”
Another call was made to the iwi chairman who said he understood the circumstances.
The ministry would not release the name of the iwi or negotiators on privacy grounds. Efforts to confirm those involved were unsuccessful.
According to the Office of Treaty Settlements, there were 35 milestones reached with claimant groups in the 12 months to June 30, 2016, and 23 milestones in the nine months to March last year.
The Herald on Sunday learned of the incident after asking government organisations to detail cases since 2016 when material had been mistakenly left unaccompanied in public.
Twenty organisations have confirmed over 75 incidents.
Those of note include the Tertiary Education Minister having to rush out a report after a Ministry of Education staffer lost a draft version in August 2016.
The draft was later found in a car belonging to a family member of the staffer.
“Their response was, ‘sh*t happens’. They are okay.” Ministry official