Otago Daily Times

Man (53) imprisoned for knife assault

- ROB KIDD Court reporter rob.kidd@odt.co.nz

A MAN who showed the ‘‘highest degree of recklessne­ss’’ when slashing at a man’s throat with a knife during a bar dispute has been jailed for 22 months.

Curtis Robert Reeves (53) was drinking at The Baaa in Great King St on October 19 when there was a terse exchange in the pub’s courtyard with another patron.

The defendant made comments that the victim looked like a woman and the man responded.

Reeves confronted the man while slipping the folding blade out of his pocket with his right hand.

It was 10cm in length and had serrated edges, Judge Kevin Phillips told the Dunedin District Court yesterday.

Reeves held the weapon behind his back and unfolded it.

He concealed it by his side as he stepped towards the victim.

‘‘He held the knife to his neck, pausing briefly, and slashed across his throat in a quick and deliberate manner,’’ the judge said.

A man unknown to the defendant then punched the victim in the head.

Both were ejected from the bar and the victim was left with a small cut on his chin which did not require medical attention.

Despite the relatively minor injury, Judge Phillips said it could have been much worse.

‘‘This was at the highest degree of recklessne­ss,’’ he said.

Reeves and the victim sat down for a restorativ­ejustice conference during which an apology from the defendant was accepted.

He admitted the man had done nothing to deserve his violent outburst, the court heard.

The victim said he had become paranoid since the incident and had given up his job as a result.

Judge Phillips gave Reeves credit for attending the conference but said his subsequent comments to a Probation officer offset that.

In a presentenc­e interview, the defendant called the man ‘‘aggravatin­g and annoying’’, which the judge regarded as an attempt to deflect the blame.

Reeves said he was carrying the knife because he had been attacked a week earlier, the court heard.

He was convicted of injuring with reckless disregard.

Defence counsel John Westgate said a prison term would be difficult for his client because he suffered from liver disease.

Reeves was assessed as a medium risk of reoffendin­g and high risk of harming others.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from New Zealand