Meeting of the mediums
Do you, Netflix, take Cinema to love and support . . .
Marriage Story, a critical standout at this year’s Venice International Film Festival, begins with some of the loveliest, most emotionally resonant film-making of American writer-director Noah Baumbach’s career.
The title doesn’t lie: We listen as Charlie (Adam Driver), a theatre director, sings the praises of his actress wife, Nicole (Scarlett Johansson), and gently ribs her for some of her more endearing flaws, and she does the same for him. These voiceover testimonials play out over two fleeting, gorgeous montages of their everyday life and work together in New York, a city whose bustling streets and tight interiors will soon recede as the movie looks west towards Los Angeles, and the marriage abruptly heads south.
The film is a lacerating blow-by-blow portrait of Charlie and Nicole’s separation and divorce, a sequence of events loosely based on the end of Baumbach’s marriage to the actress Jennifer Jason Leigh.
More than most movies, Marriage Story draws its power from your inability, as a spectator, to look away. For two hours and 15 minutes, you are trapped in this marriage with Charlie and Nicole, experiencing its death throes alongside them, and you can’t help but cherish every last precious moment of their togetherness, even when those moments become increasingly unbearable.
Looking away, of course, will be possible for the viewer who watches Marriage Story with a remote control in hand on Netflix, where it will be available to stream from December 6.
Before that, the movie will play for a week in selected New Zealand cinemas, from November 29) in line with Netflix’s recent strategy of ensuring some exclusive movie theatre play for its most anticipated year-end feature titles.
Similar plans are being made in the United States for the Netflix movies The Laundromat, Steven Soderbergh’s seething-with-a-smile comedy about the Panama Papers scandal, and majestic historical epic The King, written and directed by Australians David Michod and Joel Edgerton, and starring Timothee Chalamet.
The Laundromat goes straight to Netflix in New Zealand, but The King opens on October 18 here, two weeks before its Neflix debut.
A month-long exclusive movie-theatre window is also planned in the US for Martin Scorsese’s gangster drama The Irishman, Netflix’s biggest and most anticipated feature title of 2019. It’s a compromise solution after months of negotiations between the streaming giant and Scorsese, a longtime champion of cinemas, who had been pushing for a wide release. (In New Zealand, The Irishman is in cinemas on November 22, less than one week before it lands on Netflix).
Marriage Story and The Irishman are therefore among the latest tests of the Netflix experiment, which will force them to bear the burden of conflicting corporate priorities. Netflix wants to give its worldwide subscriber base early, preferably immediate access to major year-end movies, but it also wants to reap much-coveted plaudits, chiefly Academy Awards, from an industry that still largely regards the company’s business model with fear and contempt.
Can you disrupt an industry and earn its admiration at the same time? Alfonso Cuaron’s Roma – which began its festival run at Venice last year, enjoyed a pre-streaming movie-theatre run and appeared to come within a whisper of the best picture Oscar – answered the question with a decisive ‘‘maybe’’.
It remains a striking anomaly and a reminder of the inherent contradictions in Netflix’s strategy. It’s a movie that might never have existed in its final form without a streaming giant, but it’s also a movie whose ruminative pacing and immaculate visuals demand to be seen on the big screen.
It would be fascinating to see Netflix’s never-tobe-disclosed records on how many subscribers actually watched Roma to completion, and how many gave up partway through. (My own informal sampling suggests there are many more of the latter.)
A general audience that struggles to watch a poetic black-and-white art film from start to finish is a disheartening commentary on movie culture. But it also suggests that the convenience of streaming entertainment options is making it increasingly hard for the audience to surrender to a work of art.
The completion rates on Marriage Story will almost certainly be higher. It’s in English and features movie stars and, despite its two-hour-plus running time, it moves swiftly and with a rich vein of physical and verbal comedy that offsets the slowand-steady number it does on your emotions.
The same could be said of The Laundromat, Soderbergh’s larky and confrontational spin cycle of a movie about the wages of capitalism, a subject that has informed the film-maker’s work from The
Girlfriend Experience to Magic Mike. Although less aggressive or frenetic in its swagger than The Big
Short, the new film similarly functions as an energetic comic explainer on financial malfeasance, with a subtle undercurrent of rage that pulses unexpectedly throughout.
Antonio Banderas and a thickly Germanaccented Gary Oldman play the real-life figures Ramon Fonseca and Jurgen Mossack, heads of a law firm not known or employed for its scruples.
Together they glibly navigate us through a complex and duplicitous world of offshore accounts, shell companies and daisy-chain insurance scams, as laid out by the author Jake Bernstein in his book, Secrecy World: Inside the Panama Papers Investigation of Illicit Money Networks and the Global Elite.
Meryl Streep provides a crucial emotional counterweight as a woman who loses her husband in a tragic accident and, upon trying to collect her insurance payout, quickly finds herself a hapless victim of a new global economy where every socalled company turns out to be an empty shell.
The Laundromat cleverly adopts its own shelllike structure, tucking random surprises and subplots into secret compartments and treating its own playfully disjointed narrative as a sleight-ofhand exercise.
But I do wish Banderas and Oldman’s shtick were as funny as the movie seems to think it is.
I’ve seen The Laundromat twice and can attest that it benefits from a second viewing, which means it’s far from the worst thing to watch with a remote control in hand.
The King, by contrast, merits the sustained grandeur of a cinema presentation. With its pummelling scenes of mud-and-blood combat, its majestic, nearly monochrome widescreen images, and its beautifully broody Nicholas Britell score, this plain-spoken but unfailingly intelligent adaptation of Shakespeare’s Henriad demands and ultimately earns your surrender.
War, what is it good for? Opening on a corpsestrewn field of battle in the early 15th century, Michod’s movie continually poses that question as it charts the reluctant rise of Henry V (a superb Chalamet), a stripling who would be king. Hoping to achieve the peace that his malevolent father, Henry IV (Ben Mendelsohn), never could, the young Henry submits to a long and difficult test of his physical and psychological mettle, during which he will match wits with the arrogant young dauphin of France (a hilarious Robert Pattinson, a French taunter worthy of Monty Python and the
Holy Grail), and rely on his advisers, especially his irascible long-time friend Sir John Falstaff (a soulful Joel Edgerton). Young Kiwi actress Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie is also in the film, as Philippa. Game of Thrones has long since laid waste to the idea that scheming royals and clashing swords are
strictly the domain of the cinema. But The King doesn’t derive its splendour from non-stop narrative drive or mega-budget production values, it comes from its sense of concentration and its uniquely cinematic rhythms. It’s a movie that draws you in slowly, with a gravity that makes itself felt in the deliberation of its camera movements and the magnetic gaze of its star.
Certainly if there were any remaining doubt that Chalamet is an actor, a heart-throb and a style icon for the ages, it was decisively refuted by the movie’s Venice premiere last month, which began with (and perhaps never fully recovered from) the sight of Chalamet ruling the red carpet with his signature crown of curls and a pale grey silk-andsatin suit. Asked how he felt being at the festival for the first time, Chalamet answered with a reference to last year’s most iconic Venice arrival: ‘‘I feel like Lady Gaga on the boat.’’
It’s not the kind of thing you see every day, on Netflix or otherwise.