Driving Miss Crazy

To be patronising is to treat someone or something with apparent kindness but, ultimately, condescension.

Julie Anne Genter appears to have both nailed. It is laudable that the Associate Transport Minister cares deeply about the people she represents and is passionate about making our roads safer. We too share her view that the road toll must come down.

But it is condescending and patronising that she would promote a nonsensical target of zero road deaths by 2020. That’s little more than 18 months away, by the way.

Conventional wisdom is that one has the best opportunity to reach targets and achieve goals, even ‘‘audacious’’ ones, when they are meaningful and realistic.

Anything else can undermine the effort and become selfdefeating.

To put this into some perspective, it’s worth noting the efforts made by South Korea to reduce the number of children killed on its roads. In 1992 that number was 1566. Shocked Koreans instituted a number of measures, both practical and political, to get the figure down to a staggering 53 - 22 years later. It also cut adult deaths by two-thirds over the same period.

Back in New Zealand, what’s possibly of more concern is that Genter appears to be doubling down after her suggestion of lowering the speed limit to 70km/h for most New Zealand roads sparked outrage and was effectively run down by the prime minister.

One wonders what kind of policy avenues one might drive down in pursuit of a zero-deaths target.

The Associate Minister and her fellow Greens need to get used to one very salient fact. Yes, we need cycling, rail and other public transport options as part of the mix, but cars are not going anywhere. They are more likely to be powered by electricity in the future than the much-maligned fossil fuels, but they will remain the main transport option for the great majority of Kiwis.

Equally condescending is that Genter wants local government to ‘‘be brave enough to take the action that we know is going to save lives, and to bring the community with us’’.

That underplays the crucial role of central government in pushing the road toll either up or down. Guard rails and rumble strips make sense; taking money that might be spent on improving the quality of our roads and highways, used by millions of people and a known factor in road accidents, does not.

Genter is a Minister of the Crown, which means she should be delivering to the country facts, not fantasy.

-Stuff