Warning for NZ in rise of extreme form of Islam
Isis, Al-Qaeda, Boko Haram, and other terrorist organisations are all inspired by a particular understanding of Islam: Salafism. Salafism is an extremist, literalist, and intolerant form of Sunni Islam. Its origins are hard to trace, but it is commonly argued that 13/14th century theologian Ibn Taymiyyah strongly influenced the development of modern Salafi thought nearly 500 years later.
Salafism obtained the political power it still holds today when Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab formed an alliance with the al-Saud family during the 18th century to give birth to the Saudi version of Salafism, Wahhabism, the state religion of the current kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
As Saudi Arabia developed as a major political force, due in large part to its oil and its status as one of the West’s main allies in the Middle East, Salafism further expanded its political and geographical influence. Saudi Arabia has continued to use its wealth to propagate Wahhabi ideas.
Since the September 11 attacks, the West has become far more aware of the threats posed by Sunni extremists.
In Belgium, my country of birth, the March 22 bombings which killed 32 civilians and injured more than 300, revealed two major issues: the strong presence of Salafi ideology in Belgian Sunni mosques on the one hand and the ignorance and leniency of Belgian authorities towards this issue on the other. These two major problems are also evident in many other Western nations.
Several Belgian journalists have exposed the radical discourse of some preachers in Brussels and other cities which are heavily at odds with values such as democracy, freedom of speech, or religious tolerance.
The journalists have also exposed the lack of financial transparency (and sometimes illegal practices) of many Islamic institutions, as well as the strong ties between some of the main mosques with Salafi tendencies and Saudi Arabia.
Brussels’ most prominent mosque was placed under the direct tutelage of the Saudis when the Belgian King gave them the keys to the place of worship in 1969.
It is not hard to explain why Belgium, and other Western nations, have given so much liberty to the Saudis to propagate their intolerant extremist understanding of Islam within their countries. Economic reliance on oil is part of it, but authorities’ continued ignorance of Islamic history and its varied schools of thoughts resulting in considering Salafism as representative of Islam is a factor. NZ can learn from Belgium. First, it is important to recognise a problem and not to underestimate it. The recent hate speech controversy, involving a cleric from the at-Taqwa mosque in Manukau, is only the tip of the iceberg and follows a well-established pattern of other events involving Salafi clerics preaching in New Zealand, such as Egyptian cleric Sheikh Abu Abdullah a couple of years ago. It would be naive to think NZ’s Sunnioriented mosques are immune to Salafi ideology and its intolerant and sometimes violent interpretation of Islam.
It would equally be naive to believe NZ is free from economic ties with the Saudi Kingdom, as the controversial Saudi farm deal recently underlined. The extent to which these ties influence the ideological makeup of Islam in NZ is uncertain.
It is important NZ doesn’t imitate the leniency of other Western nations towards these issues. And it’s important to understand and adopt the right attitude towards Islamic extremism. Extremism thrives on division. Mainstream stereotyping and discrimination against Muslims has helped Salafism, and its Manichean worldview, to grow in Europe. It is therefore critical NZ should remain an inclusive and tolerant nation by embracing its diverse Muslim community.
Most Muslims, conservatives or not, reject violence and intolerance. They are allies in the fight against terrorism.
By creating a New Zealand model of multicultural citizenship, where Kiwis of all ethnic groups and faiths live with and are supportive of each other, we can become a role model for the world and avoid replicating other nations’ mistakes.
Nicolas Pirsoul is a doctoral candidate in politics and international relations at the University of Auckland. His research interests include issues around identity politics, indigenous recognition, democracy and Middle Eastern politics.