‘More damage than we expected’
$20m repair job to rotten units at halfway mark
One of Auckland’s largest leaky building repairs is halfway through, as dozens of contractors fix the rotten Parnell Terraces in a $20 million-plus building job spread across three years.
Protective building wrap covers scaffolding over the entire 81 terraced units in six blocks in the Quay Park/Parnell area between The Strand, Roynane St, Ngaoho Pl and the main trunk railway line.
The townhouse complex is three levels high and one contractor said 60 per cent to 70 per cent of all structures were being demolished and replaced by new buildings.
Residents left their places last year and won’t be able to return until next year.
The townhouses had monolithic cladding and internal gutterings and suffered extensive water damage.
Consultant Maynard Marks is managing the project. Corbel Construction is the head contractor.
Work began last November and is not expected to finish until well into next year.
Monolithic cladding had been stripped from exteriors and was being replaced by NuWall, an aluminium-style cladding, a contractor said.
Michael Rehm, body corporate chairman, said the entire project would cost at least $20m although it was estimated three years ago in a court document to cost $11.7m.
“We knew that opening up these buildings would be like a can of worms. There’s a lot more damage than we ever expected because there’s fire issues as well. None of this adds value to the owners but Auckland Council requires that the buildings be brought up to the current code.
“One of the things which bled us dry is time delays and every single day we had to wait cost us an extra $3000,” said Rehm adding that he was a rare owner/occupier.
“It’s been a financial nightmare for me. I bought my place for $250,000 in 2006. Two years later, we found out it was leaky.
“I’ve spent already about $150,000 in repair levies and there’s another one to go, probably another $60,000 to $70,000,” Rehm said.
Most of the $20m was coming from owners who contributed 75 per cent and the rest came from the government’s Financial Assistance Package, Rehm said.
About a quarter of the unit owners were borrowing money from the banks but the rest had to pay cash, he said.
“We all knew it was going to come. But three-quarters of the places are owned by investors. A lot of people will try to sell up at the end of it.”
The original developers had sold their company and created a new company, Rehm said. No money was being paid by them “because no assets were easily attainable”.
Ground rent was costing around $9000 for each unit annually he said “but that’s nothing compared to where it’s going to go”.
In 2015, a decision from the High Court at Auckland described repairs: “Extensive work is required. The estimated repair cost is $11.7m.”
Tim Rainey of Rainey Law has acted for the owners who succeeded in getting a scheme of repair under the Unit Titles Act 2010.
The townhouses are on leasehold land owned by Ngati Whatua O Orakei Whai Rawa and that aspect has also caused issues. In 2011, Parnell Terraces’ owners went to arbitration against the iwi over a long-running dispute on a ground rent increase.
On June 30, 2000 the Herald reported on Parnell Terraces’ creation, calling it an affordable option.
At the time units sold from $194,000 to $210,000.
Broadway Developments said neither board members Neil Hammil nor Lindsay Kennedy were available for comment.