Pros & cons

Bill English maintains he still has the support to stay on as leader while in Opposition. Claire Trevett weighs up the potential contenders for the role. Judith Collins Pros: Definitely has the mongrel required for Opposition and the ambition to match. Not squeamish about tackling Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern where others might hold their punches. Has support in National circles as one of its right wing. Cons: Has some political baggage and is polarising. May not be able to secure confidence of whole caucus — carries the risk of dividing it. Simon Bridges Pros: Young enough to be “new generation” change but experienced enough to know what he’s doing. Well versed on the economy and regions. Aggressive in Opposition. Would be first Maori Prime Minister if he made it that far. Cons: Strong accent, wears ambition too openly and treads fine line between holding Government to account and being obstructive for the sake of it. Opinion of him is divided in caucus. Mark Mitchell Pros: Former security contractor in Iraq is likely the only politician who has shot at people, but is wellliked and even-tempered. Works hard on relations with media and other politicians. Believes National should mend bridges with New Zealand First, and is one of the best-placed to do so. No political baggage. Cons: Intellectual rigour unknown, not yet seen as a heavyweight. Low public profile. Has been tested under fire literally — but not yet in politics. Then again, neither were John Key or Ardern. Amy Adams Pros: A steady hand with brains and a measured approach. Was one of former PM Key’s favourites. Impressive in her ministerial portfolios. Cons: Low profile in Opposition and may struggle with the likeability factor. Is also yet to show if she has the “mongrel” required. May be consigned to good deputy material. Dr Jonathan Coleman Pros: Combative, which is good for Opposition. Not ideological and showed guts standing for the leadership before. Cons: Has little support and is unlikely to build it. Not popular enough in caucus or the wider public. Nikki Kaye Pros: One of National’s socially liberal MPs, like Bridges represents change but has experience. High public profile, especially in Auckland. Knows her enemy well, having beaten Ardern in Auckland Central. Has adjusted quickly to Opposition. Cons: Socially liberal views could make National’s base nervous. Doubtful she could muster enough support to beat Bridges and Collins.