Global vaccination project faces conflict, instability and mistrust
Arifullah Khan had just administered another polio vaccine when the gunfire blasted from the nearby hills.
“It happened so suddenly. There was so much gunfire it felt like an explosion,” he said, recalling details of the attack five years ago in Pakistan’s Bajaur tribal region near the Afghan border.
A bullet shattered his thigh and he fell to the ground. His childhood friend and partner in the vaccination campaign, Ruhollah, lay bleeding on the ground in front of him.
“I couldn’t move,” Khan said. “I watched him lying right in front of me as he took his last breath.”
In Pakistan, delivering vaccines can be deadly. Militants and radical religious groups spread claims that the polio vaccine is a Western ploy to sterilise Muslim children or turn them away from religion. More than 100 health workers, vaccinators and security officials involved in polio vaccination have been killed since 2012.
The violence is an extreme example of the difficulties many poorer and developing countries across Asia, Africa, the Middle East and Latin America face as they tackle the monumental task of vaccinating their populations against Covid-19.
It’s not just the problem of affording vaccines or being at the back of the line behind wealthy countries in receiving them.
Poor infrastructure often means roads are treacherous and electricity is sporadic for the refrigerators vital to preserving vaccines. Wars and insurgencies endanger vaccinators. Corruption can siphon away funds, and vaccination campaign planners must sometimes navigate through multiple armed factions.
“The most challenging areas . . . are conflict settings, where outbreaks of violence hinder vaccinations, and areas where misinformation is circulating, which discourages community participation,” said Unicef’s deputy chief of global immunisation, Benjamin Schreiber.
Many nations are relying on Covax, an international system aimed at ensuring equitable access to vaccines, though it is already short on funding.
Unicef, which runs immunisation programmes worldwide, is gearing up to help procure and administer Covid19 vaccines, Schreiber said. It has stockpiled half a billion syringes and aims to provide 70,000 refrigerators, mostly solar powered, he said.
The agency aims to transport 850 tonnes of Covid-19 vaccines a month next year, double its usual annual monthly rate for other vaccines, Unicef’s executive director, Henrietta Fore, said in a statement.
The situation can vary widely from country to country.
Mexico is expected to start immunisations soon. The military will handle distribution, and the government has promised free vaccines for Mexico’s nearly 130 million inhabitants by the end of 2021.
Meanwhile, Haiti, the Western Hemisphere’s poorest country, has yet to announce any vaccination plans.
Health experts worry that widespread rumours could set back vaccinations — including claims that hospitals will give fatal injections to inflate Covid19 death figures and receive more foreign aid.
The African Centres for Disease Control and Prevention is leading a continent-wide effort to vaccinate Africa’s 1.3 billion people in 54 countries. The agency is co-ordinating efforts to obtain doses and seeking World Bank help in funding — estimating it will take US$10 billion to acquire, distribute and administer the vaccines.
The aim is to vaccinate 60 per cent of Africa’s population within two years — about 700 million people — more than the continent has done in the past, said John Nkengasong, director of the African CDC.
“The time for action is now,” said Nkengasong.
“The West cannot defeat Covid-19 alone. It must be defeated all over the world, and that includes Africa.”
Congo underscores the obstacles the campaign faces.
The country has overcome Ebola outbreaks with vaccination campaigns. But it struggled in eastern Congo, where Allied Democratic Forces rebels stage frequent attacks and other armed groups vie for control of mineral riches.
Rough terrain and insecurity meant vaccinators had trouble getting to all areas. Some came under attack.
Rumours flew about the Ebola vaccines, including the idea they were meant to kill people, said Dr Maurice Kakule, an Ebola survivor who worked in vaccination campaigns. Education programmes overcame much of the resistance, but similar suspicions are spreading about the Covid-19 vaccine, he said.
Civil wars present perhaps the greatest obstacles.
In Yemen, the health system has collapsed under six years of war between Houthi rebels who control the north and government-allied factions in the south.
Yemen saw its first outbreak of polio in 15 years this summer, centred in the northern province of Saada. Vaccinators haven’t been able to work there the past two years, in part because of security fears, Unicef said. Agencies rushed to give new inoculations in parts of the north and south in November and December.
Cholera and diphtheria have been rampant, and, once again, Yemen faces a new surge in hunger. UN officials have warned of potential famine in 2021.
No plans for Covid-19 vaccinations have been announced yet, whether by the Houthis, southern authorities or WHO and Unicef.
Only half of Yemen’s health facilities remain functional. Roads, power networks and other infrastructure have been devastated.
The Houthis have hampered some programmes, trying to wrest concessions from UN agencies, including blocking a shipment of cholera vaccines amid a 2017 outbreak.
“Even the mildest and normally preventable diseases can prove fatal due to a lack of healthcare access in a conflict setting,” said Wasim Bahja, the Yemen country director for International Medical Corps.
In Pakistan, public distrust was fuelled when the CIA in 2011 used a scam vaccination programme to identify the hideout of al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden, leading to the special forces raid that killed him.
Pakistan, Afghanistan and Nigeria are the only countries in the world where polio is still endemic.
There have been 82 new polio cases this year alone, largely because vaccinations were suspended due to the pandemic, said Dr Rana Safdar, who co-ordinates the polio vaccination campaigns.
The Bajaur region, where Khan was shot, remains one of the more dangerous areas, Safdar said.
Khan tried to explain the deep mistrust in his region.
Deeply conservative tribal elders “believe the vaccine is the reason the young people who were given it as children are disrespectful and show little concern for Islamic traditions and values”.
“Everyone is scared” of Covid-19, he said. “But they are suspicious of Western things.”
Khan said he signed up to administer polio vaccines because he was paid the equivalent of US$56 for just a few days’ work.
“I needed to feed my family.”
He will likely sign up to deliver Covid-19 vaccines as well.
“But first I would check if there is any danger there,” he said.
The West cannot defeat Covid-19 alone. It must be defeated all over the world, and that includes Africa. John Nkengasong, director of The African Centres for Disease Control and Prevention