Trouble with the truth
Famously miserable Smiths frontman Morrissey once sang that ‘‘some girls are bigger than others’’. He went on to opine that ‘‘some girls’ mothers are bigger than other girls’ mothers’’.
Morrissey was pointing out that, no matter what we regard as the ideal, or what is portrayed in the latest air-brushing of history and hip widths, life contains the odd annoying, uncomfortable truth.
Here’s a couple more: some people have deep, religious convictions that don’t necessarily conform to the more progressive, enlightened view of their peers; and sport is populated by fiercely competitive people, some of whom don’t particularly like each other.
Two men supposedly behaving badly in sport this week have revealed as much about our ability to accommodate those inconvenient truths and the freedoms that underpin them, as they have about the sportsmen themselves.
Australian rugby star Israel Folau is a deeply religious person who doesn’t care much for homosexuality. You probably picked up his religious conviction from his first name; the latter was clarified in loud and controversial terms when he tweeted, in response to a question, that God’s plan for gay people was Hell.
Most people will not agree with his vision; many have gone on to social media to register their outrage. Rugby Australia is understood to be working hard to silence him, and sponsors are threatening to walk.
But silencing Folau doesn’t alter this particular uncomfortable truth, and it serves a greater evil, undermining freedom of speech in a society that regards itself as sophisticated, mature and inclusive.
Inclusive, yes. But only if you agree with a largely unwritten code of behaviour and beliefs.
New Zealand Commonwealth Games gold medal mountain-biker Sam Gaze is another perceived to have broken the code, to have muddied the waters of an acceptable narrative.
He battled hard for that top step on the podium against arch-rival and fellow Kiwi Anton Cooper. It was a reversal of fortune from the race in Glasgow four years earlier.
Two things are clear: Gaze is a fiercely competitive person who was bitterly disappointed to miss that Glasgow gold; and the two athletes do not like each other. At all.
That happens. It’s part of life. Even when athletes are wearing the same colours of club and/or country.
The winner gave Cooper more than a steely gaze at the end of his hard-fought race. Cue another predictable diarrhoea of outrage.
Gaze has since taken to social media to apologise for his actions, but there is a sense that this has been done merely to obscure the more obvious, but inconvenient truth. To create another deemed more acceptable.
Which leads us to another uncomfortable truth: Out there in the ether, lurking menacingly in the darker avenues and on-ramps of the cyber highway, is an amorphous huddle of malevolence, with no real or official affiliation, but with one clear objective: a redistribution of opinion, societal values and moral infrastructure along narrower, more idealistic, lines.
It’s not clear how big this group is, or even where they live. But it is clear that they are potentially more dangerous than the odd sports star with outdated views or poor discipline.
Inclusive, yes. But only if you agree.