The Post

The inside look that fails to get inside

Netflix doco on Michelle Obama is a thoughtful scrapbook that could have offered more, finds Hank Stuever.

-

Becoming, a Netflix documentar­y about Michelle Obama’s arena-filling, 34-city book tour, is filled from start to finish with everything everyone already knows and presumably admires about the former first lady, especially anyone who read her best-selling memoir.

Nadia Hallgren’s film is a thoughtful scrapbook, briskly perused – an inside look that never gets too inside.

Actually, the whole thing could be somewhat scepticall­y received as an inside job, as so many documentar­ies about the ultrafamou­s are these days, with the line blurred between ‘‘subject’’ and ‘‘producer’’.

It was made by Michelle and Barack Obama’s Higher Ground Production­s, which has an exclusive deal with Netflix (and has already produced an Oscar-winning documentar­y with last year’s American Factory).

To note this fact is not a criticism so much as a willing acceptance of the ground rules. Those who come here for their reaffirmin­g booster shot of Obama-era hopefulnes­s will get what they’re looking for.

Those coming for something else – a news scoop or a bolder contextual take, such as the recent

Hillary docuseries (streaming on TVNZ OnDemand) – won’t get that, but can still enjoy the sense of backstage access.

Michelle Obama’s presence still electrifie­s any room she walks into, whether it’s as big as an arena or as small as a community centre meeting room.

‘‘Everyone in the world knows who she is,’’ says her wryly observant older brother, Craig Robinson. ‘‘That’s incredible – everyone in the world knows who my sister is. What is that? That’s dumb. Nobody should have to deal with that. Noone. No brother should have to deal with their sister being the most popular person in the world.’’ This degree of notoriety and potential power is

Becoming’s central theme, as its subject and the world around her consider the ramificati­ons of taking life’s next step.

Oddly absent is any scene in which Obama is hunkered down with the messy business of actually writing her memoir (also called

Becoming), a process which has been known to bring authors low. Instead of typing and editing and discussion­s about what to put in and what to leave out, we start at the book tour itself, and all that it entails: Sitting for makeup and hair, entering and exiting through kitchens and long hallways, getting into the SUV and then getting out of it.

Such scenes come with their own insights. We see some of Obama’s rapport with her Secret Service detail, including Allen Taylor, the agent first assigned to protect her in 2008.

We meet her loyal stylist/consultant, Meredith Koop, who Obama says helped turn fashion into a useful tool ‘‘rather than being a victim of it’’.

(‘‘Is it the style to have your belt so high now?’’ her brother asks, when Obama gets ready to go onstage in an outfit with a fierce array of belt buckles. ‘‘I just asked!’’ he protests when the women in the room start to hiss at him.)

Becoming is least interestin­g when it adheres to the structure of Obama’s well-known biographic­al highlights. It is most interestin­g whenever she is in the company of trusted friends, family and colleagues – starting with her appealing mother, Marian Shields Robinson, and their visits to Craig’s home for a family lunch (‘‘Craig always has a good supply of wine. I love coming here and drinking his wine’’ Marian declares, to which her indignant daughter replies, ‘‘I have wine, too’’).

Or to the Southside Chicago house where Michelle and Craig were raised and where most of the family’s well-worn furniture still sits, perhaps awaiting historic preservati­on.

Becoming is most memorable, however, as a chronicle of Obama’s interactio­ns with the public, who stand in line for hours to get their copies of

Becoming signed and, in turn, receive more than just a nod. They remain forever captivated by her, as a person and as an ideal.

‘‘Look them in the eye. Take in the story,’’ Obama says about these encounters, whether a book has been bought or not.

She sits in a circle of chairs with a group of teenage girls and offers unlimited encouragem­ent. She sits with a group of black women at their church and together they compare notes on what Barack Obama’s presidency meant, as a personal narrative and as history.

In this sense, the footage feels like it could be repurposed years from now into a longer, deeper and more complete documentar­y. The context is still evolving.

Obama is proud of her and her husband’s accomplish­ments, and remorseful about the expression­s of racism they endured the entire way.

‘‘My grandfathe­r’s grandmothe­r was in bondage – it’s important to keep that truth right there,’’ she says. ‘‘Barack and I were living with an awareness that we ourselves were a provocatio­n.’’

On the subject of today’s political climate, the high road is still taken, but the Becoming tour provides an opportunit­y for Obama to look at her audiences directly and lament the weaker turnout from black and female voters in the 2016 election (and the 2010 and 2014 midterms).

‘‘I understand the people who voted for Trump,’’ she says. ‘‘But people who didn’t vote at all? After all that work, they just couldn’t be bothered to vote, at all. That’s my trauma.’’ – The Washington Post

Becoming is streaming now on Netflix.

Michelle Obama’s presence still electrifie­s any room she walks into.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from New Zealand