The Press

Korea, Iran and nuke diplomacy

-

binding internatio­nal law. Saudi Arabia also hasn’t signed.

Lastly, we have the 2017 Treaty on the Prohibitio­n of Nuclear Weapons, which finally and explicitly makes nuclear weapons illegal under internatio­nal law.

Previously considered impossible, the treaty was a dramatic, people-driven effort for which the Internatio­nal Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons won the 2017 Nobel Peace Prize.

The nine nuclear-armed states have shunned this treaty, along with their allies that expect to be protected by nuclear weapons (including Australia).

So that’s the legal landscape. What does it tell us about the Iran deal and North Korea’s nuclear programme? It tells us we should keep the Iran deal intact, both in terms of preventing the further spread of nuclear weapons and getting North Korea (and others) to take nuclear disarmamen­t seriously. Iran is inside the NPT, not developing nuclear weapons. North Korea is outside the NPT with nuclear weapons.

President Trump’s actions essentiall­y punish Iran for nuclear compliance and reward North Korea for nuclear defiance. That risks making nuclear weapons look useful – not a judicious strategy.

Last Friday’s inter-Korean summit happened because the leadership­s in both Seoul and Pyongyang wanted it to work.

Nuclear disarmamen­t relies on building the same sense of mutual interest. To prevent the production and use of weapons of mass destructio­n, countries are better served in the long run by negotiatio­ns than by bombs.

The Iran deal was the result of decades of efforts. To hammer it out, diplomats from Russia, China, the US, EU and Iran spent countless days, weeks and months sitting face to face. Same goes for the preparatio­ns of the inter-Korean summit. This human interactio­n is good for peace – it builds lasting trust and opens unexpected opportunit­ies for co-operation.

Contrast that with the bombing of Syria in response to reports of chemical weapons attacks.

Not only do missiles further endanger the civilian population­s, but they set back the prospects of peace, mediation and co-operation amongst the states involved in conflicts.

It is better to support civil society and build space for human rights, rather than build up a sense of injustice among local people with sanctions and bombs.

We’re privileged to live in a country where these matters seem distant. We should feel a responsibi­lity in this privilege to redouble our support for peaceful resolution to tension and conflict.

With our new prime minister generating prominence for us on the internatio­nal stage, New Zealand has an opportunit­y to step up our diplomatic efforts in this area as a champion for peace and disarmamen­t. We should do so.

Thomas Nash led the global campaign to ban cluster bombs, co-founded UK-based disarmamen­t group Article 36 and served on the board of the Nobel Prize-winning Internatio­nal Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons. Maty Nikkhou-Brien is executive director of the New Zealand Institute of Internatio­nal Affairs (NZIIA). Before the NZIIA role, Maty founded and directed the Paris and Wellington-based think-tank Diplospher­e.

 ?? AP ?? President Hassan Rouhani at a ceremony to mark ‘‘National Nuclear Day’’, in Tehran, Iran, last month. Rouhani has said that despite many attempts, the US has "failed to destroy" the landmark 2015 deal between Iran and world powers.
AP President Hassan Rouhani at a ceremony to mark ‘‘National Nuclear Day’’, in Tehran, Iran, last month. Rouhani has said that despite many attempts, the US has "failed to destroy" the landmark 2015 deal between Iran and world powers.
 ?? AP ?? North Korean President Kim Jong Un, left, and his South Korean counterpar­t, Moon Jae In, at the border village of Panmunjom in the Demilitari­zed Zone late last week. Kim may have felt his nuclear weapons programme gave him a trump card, say the writers.
AP North Korean President Kim Jong Un, left, and his South Korean counterpar­t, Moon Jae In, at the border village of Panmunjom in the Demilitari­zed Zone late last week. Kim may have felt his nuclear weapons programme gave him a trump card, say the writers.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from New Zealand