The Press

Well done Hamilton for doing the right thing

- Joel Maxwell

It was a gorgeous collection of Pa¯ keha¯ , but now they’ve gone and broken up the set. I could be wrong here (and feel free to let me know otherwise) but Hamilton’s council table appears to be so non-Ma¯ ori its collective headshots look like the results page from a Google search for the keywords ‘‘middle-aged’’, ‘‘caucasian’’ and ‘‘stock photo’’.

The Pa¯ keha¯ is strong in this group.

I bring this up because, following a Hamilton council vote, the city will now have five Ma¯ ori representa­tives appointed across a clutch of its committees. These representa­tives can vote.

This could be the best way forward for councils to get around the shockwave of resistance to moves to create Ma¯ ori wards.

Other councils around the country have approved Ma¯ ori wards, only to have them killed by public-initiated referendum­s. The good thing about these Hamilton appointmen­ts is that Johnny and Jane Redneck can’t get rid of them through a referendum. You’re stuck with them, Johnny, and the evil racism they apparently represent.

I think Hamilton, like most councils, is in desperate need of Ma¯ ori voices. I had a quick read of the councillor biographie­s on the council website and, sadly, nobody was putting up their hand and admitting to being tangata whenua. (If you are, don’t be shy.)

It begins at the top. I submit for your considerat­ion Mayor Andrew King. Mayor King is a successful businessma­n, who started back in the 90s ‘‘installing and maintainin­g plastic extrusion machinery’’. ‘‘Microwave repeater equipment and push-to-talk radio systems’’ were part of his origin story. I’m not sure what the words for plastic extrusions are in te reo. He has a nice smile, though.

Meanwhile, Deputy Mayor Martin Gallagher ‘‘developed his keen interest in politics as a child, on a trip to visit family in England in 1960’’. Sigh.

From there the rest of the council table is a long, tall cup of milky tea: cycling and ballroom-dancing enthusiast­s, former cops, rugby club committee members. However, while these councillor­s might look like a collection of ageing Ken dolls, some of them have more than just a hollow noggin plopped out of one of the mayor’s extruders.

Yes, I’ve given them stick for a lack of diversity, but the five councillor­s and Mayor King who voted for the Ma¯ ori appointmen­ts are a shining example of decent, calm, rational leadership. The truth is that democracy won’t crumble as a result. Instead the city will benefit from the expertise added to the committees. It’s just the smart thing to do, and I salute the men and women who voted yes.

Contrast that with the jittery hysteria of councillor Garry Mallet. In a region where half a million hectares of Ma¯ ori land was confiscate­d by Pa¯ keha¯ , he stood at the council table and called the appointmen­t of five Ma¯ ori representa­tives racist. He said the decision was ‘‘evil’’ and was essentiall­y circumvent­ing the opportunit­y for a referendum. (The words he used on Stuff were ‘‘snuck in’’.)

What I think is evil is that a semblance of – legally obliged – partnershi­p with Ma¯ ori has to be snuck in at all, so belatedly, in a region with one of the country’s biggest iwi. But if sneaking is required to do the right thing, and push aside the Mallets of this country, then I say sneak away.

We need more of this sort of thing. If Ma¯ ori wards can be shot down by swathes of rednecks, then perhaps the councils that have had their decisions overturned can look at these appointmen­ts as a way to do the right thing. (If you want some interestin­g facts to understand why there should be better partnershi­ps between councils and iwi, I recommend reading Stuff’s new interactiv­e piece, New Zealand Made/Na¯ Niu Tı¯reni.)

I know, the whingers will say that such appointmen­ts as Hamilton’s are anti-democratic. But every other decision made by councillor­s around the country isn’t subjected to referendum­s by the bitter and mean-spirited.

Those desperate to extract every drop of democracy from their council can vote in the regular elections, anyway. I guess this is where the likes of Mayor King and his fellow councillor­s have shown real leadership. They have taken a risk – balancing doing the right thing with losing votes. But if they do their jobs well during this term, the voters won’t care about this sort of thing.

Personally I wish I could be there for the first committee meetings in Hamilton with guaranteed iwi representa­tion – even if the newest members had to be snuck in.

For anyone interested, here was the vote. For: Paula Southgate, Angela O’Leary, Dave Macpherson, Ryan Hamilton, Geoff Taylor and Andrew King. Against: Martin Gallagher, Garry Mallet, Mark Bunting, and Leo Tooman.

The good thing about these appointmen­ts is that Johnny and Jane Redneck can’t get rid of them through a referendum. You’re stuck with them, Johnny.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from New Zealand