The Timaru Herald

Trim waving wands for magic buds

-

full of anecdote and detail (and much in the form of an extended essay). His digression­s outlining their unique career paths provide further proof that they are motivated not by money but by public service – and, like the biography of astronaut Kathy Sullivan, are very interestin­g in themselves.

The real value of The Fifth Risk lies in its insight into the importance of considered,

apolitical, long-term government, but its impetus lies in the risk of losing that under an uninformed Trump administra­tion. The antiTrump angle is strong, the prologue setting out how, the day after Trump’s election, government department­s were ready to brief the new administra­tion but many heard nothing for days, if not weeks, and when representa­tives did appear, or when appointmen­ts were made, many had little knowledge of or interest in the areas to which they were assigned.

The consequent threat is the defunding – or the eliminatio­n – of important government functions. Lewis provides little conclusive evidence of this, though he hints at a reorganisa­tion of ‘‘Rural Developmen­t’’.

There is a fundamenta­l difficulty in writing about current events like this, especially when it involves a transition­ing government. Neverthele­ss, The Fifth Risk is still very effective in outlining the unapprecia­ted workings of benign government, whatever the risks to it might be.

– Charles Cole

 ??  ?? Wisteria can be too vigorous, so cut back long growth now. Below: a piece of wood under pumpkins will protect them from rot.
Wisteria can be too vigorous, so cut back long growth now. Below: a piece of wood under pumpkins will protect them from rot.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from New Zealand