New doubts over airline’s safety claim
Questions over Lion Air claim that technical problem had been fixed
New details about the crashed Lion Air’s jet previous flight have cast more doubt on the Indonesian airline’s claim to have fixed the plane’s technical problems.
The developments came as hundreds of personnel continued to search the sea for victims and the plane’s fuselage.
The brand new Boeing 737 Max 8 plane plunged into the Java Sea on Monday, just minutes after taking off from the Indonesian capital Jakarta, killing all 189 people on board.
Herson, head of Bali-Nusa Tenggara Airport Authority, said the pilot on the plane’s previous flight on Sunday from Bali requested to return to the airport not long after takeoff but then reported the problem had been resolved. Several passengers have described the problem as a terrifying loss of altitude.
Lion Air has said the unspecified problem was fixed after Sunday’s flight, but the fatal flight’s pilots also made a “return to base” (RTB) request not long after takeoff.
“Shortly after requesting RTB, the pilot then contacted the control tower again to inform that the plane had run normally and would not return” to Bali’s Ngurah Rai airport, said Herson, who uses a single name. “The captain said the problem was resolved and he decided to continue the trip to Jakarta.”
Data from flight-tracking websites shows both flights had highly erratic speed and altitude after takeoff, though confirmation is required from data recorded by the aircraft’s “black box” flight recorders.
Investigators displayed one of the jet’s two flight recorders at a news conference yesterday, later confirmed to be the flight data recorder, and said they would immediately attempt to upload information and begin analysis.
“In principle, all data we have obtained, including flight data and air navigation, and also from other sources — we find that there have indeed been problems” with the plane, said Haryo Satmiko, deputy chairman of the National Transport Safety Committee. “We will prove more technical problems with data recorded in the black box.”
The steel-encased memory unit of the recovered flight recorder had separated from its base plate, showing the plane hit the sea at tremendous
speed, he said. Investigators say that is also indicated by the searchand-rescue effort finding many body parts rather than intact victims.
Satmiko said investigators had already contacted the pilot of the plane’s Sunday flight. The problems with it were “just as it circulates on media and social media”, he said, referring to accounts of passengers.
One of them, Diah Mardani, told a current affairs television programme this week that after takeoff “the plane suddenly fell, then rose, then fell again harder and shook”. “All the passengers started shouting God is Great,” she said. “The atmosphere was very tense.”
She said she was travelling with a group of more than 50 colleagues and
many were crying with relief after landing in Jakarta.
A team from the US National Transportation Safety Board including Boeing experts has joined the Indonesian investigation.
The Lion Air crash is the worst airline disaster in Indonesia since 1997, when 234 people died on a Garuda flight near Medan. Indonesian airlines were barred in 2007 from flying to Europe because of safety concerns, though several were allowed to resume services in the following decade. The ban was completely lifted in June. The US lifted a decade-long ban in 2016.
Lion Air, a discount carrier, is one of Indonesia’s youngest and biggest airlines.