Bombshell admission in raid
The head of the Defence Force has accepted that a 3-year-old girl appears to have been killed during a New Zealand-led raid in Afghanistan.
The bombshell admission is believed to be the first time New Zealand’s military officials have acknowledged the likelihood of the girl’s death.
Top military brass this week faced questions about a “cover-up” and why the Defence Force until 2014 said allegations of civilian deaths during Operation Burnham were false, despite a report by coalition forces in 2010 concluding they were possible.
The Government inquiry was spurred by the 2017 book Hit & Run ,in which journalists Nicky Hager and Jon Stephenson alleged six civilians — including a young girl name Fatima — were killed and 15 others wounded during the NZSAS-led raid against insurgents in August 2010.
In the closing minutes of the inquiry’s final public hearing yesterday, Chief of Defence Air Marshal Kevin Short was asked whether he accepted it appeared Fatima had been killed in the operation.
“Appears to, yes.” Short replied. The NZDF has since 2014 accepted civilian deaths may have been possible, but Short’s comment is believed to be the first public acknowledgment of the particular claim.
Until as recently as a few months ago, the Weekend Herald understands senior personnel in the NZDF were still denying Fatima’s death.
Moments earlier, Short told the inquiry that not all civilian deaths were war crimes, evoking a gasp from the public gallery, and that the NZDF had only targeted armed fighters.
“I am saying that because if you are a member of an organised armed group and you behave as such then you actually forfeit the protections you have as a civilian,” he said.
“I say that because this was an armed group . . .
“There is enough information to say they were armed. They were organised and we had to destroy their weapons.”
But he said there was no evidence to confirm the civilian deaths.
Stephenson’s lawyer, Davey Salmon, then asked: “So the problem is you think a girl was probably killed and that probably others were injured, but you’re not looking to check and while you continue to do that, you will continue to be able to take that line, won’t you?” “Yes,” Short replied.
Hit & Run described Fatima’s death in the arms of her mother, Khadija.
A 2010 report by the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) concluded a gun-sight malfunction on a US Army helicopter led to rounds accidentally hitting two buildings during the operation — possibly killing villagers. New Zealand troops were cleared of wrongdoing.
The book quoted one local as saying: “Although Fatima was only 3 years old, she was already attending school. She was very beautiful and intelligent. She was in her mother’s arms when a piece of shrapnel hit her head.”
Hit & Run alleged Fatima’s sister and brother — Hanifa, 4, and Abdullah, 7 — were also wounded.
Khadija was said to have undergone a six-hour journey to hospital over Afghanistan’s broken roads, “leaving behind her dead child to be buried”.
The book was heavily criticised by the Defence Force after its release and the authors accused of significant inaccuracies.
Former Defence Minister Wayne Mapp said he was told civilians may have been killed during a New Zealand-led raid in Afghanistan but didn’t tell the public or the prime minister because he didn’t think there was enough hard proof.
Mapp — who was the Minister of Defence from 2008 until late 2011 — yesterday told the inquiry he had been briefed about the report in the Beehive in September 2011.
“I now have a fragmentary memory of being told . . . that there was no evidence of civilian casualties but that it was possible that civilian casualties may have been caused during Operation Burnham,” he said.
But he said because there had been no detailed evidence to confirm the deaths, he had never passed the information on to former Prime Minister Sir John Key’s office.
“I was not left with any reason to think I had to take further action . . . I thought, on the basis of what I’ve been told, I can’t take this matter any further, because there was no actual evidence,” Mapp said.
“The decisions made were my decisions . . . I accept that.”
Based on incorrect advice from the Defence Force in 2010 that the report had found there was “no way” civilians had died during the attack, Mapp had in April 2011 told media the allegations had been proven false.
Yesterday he said there was not enough evidence to issue a new public statement after being told about the ISAF report’s actual conclusion, and that he thought Key’s office would not have been convinced enough to approve one.
“I should have at least talked to someone else, but I didn’t . . . In hindsight it might be a wrong assessment but it’s the one I made,” Mapp said.
He described Stephenson as the “hero” of the situation for raising further details about the possible deaths in 2014.
Retired Colonel Jim Blackwell — the director of Special Operations in 2011 — this week told the inquest he had briefed Mapp after receiving the report, and that he had conveyed its conclusions properly. “I certainly didn’t cover up anything,” Blackwell said.
Pressed on whether he had been briefed properly and given enough detail by Blackwell, Mapp yesterday said he could not recall the details of the briefings and denied falling on his own sword to protect Blackwell.
Former Defence chief Rhys Jones earlier told the inquiry he could not recall seeing or being briefed about the document while in the top job.
The inquiry has heard that Mapp’s successor, Jonathan Coleman, set the public record straight in 2014 after being handed a copy of the ISAF report that had been sitting in a Defence Force headquarters safe for about three years.
The Defence Force says its claims civilian deaths were “unfounded” were based on a misunderstanding of the ISAF report by New Zealand’s top SAS officer in Afghanistan in 2010.
The NZDF’s then senior national officer, Brigadier Christopher Parsons, told the inquiry he had only been allowed to see one paragraph of the report in September, 2010, and as a result incorrectly reported back no civilians had died.
This week’s hearing is the last scheduled public session of the $7 million Government inquiry, which is being run by former Prime Minister Sir Geoffrey Palmer and Supreme Court Justice Sir Terence Arnold.
The deadline for their final report has been extended until March 2020.