Shift from non-GAAP bottom lines good for stock prices
Indexes: Dow down 0.4pc, S&P down 0.2pc, Nasdaq down 0.1pc
adjustments tend to make their profits appear stronger.
After an 8 per cent rise in 2017, the S&P 500 is trading at 17.8 times expected earnings, a level many investors consider expensive and increases the risk of a market selloff. But the expected earnings in that valuation are adjusted, not GAAP.
To the extent that companies use non-GAAP accounting less this year than in recent years, investors may feel more comfortable paying higher valuations for their stocks.
“You’re getting more conservative in your earnings approach rather than more aggressive,” said Phil Blancato, head of Ladenburg Thalmann Asset Management in New York. “That’s exactly why I don’t think current PEs are very expensive.”
Following new accounting standards covering the taxation of stock-based compensation, Google parent company Alphabet Inc stopped excluding stock-based compensation from its costs in the first quarter. Facebook Inc said it would no longer emphasise non-GAAP expenses, income, tax rate or earnings per share.
Responding to a new standard on revenue recognition, Microsoft Corp recently said it will switch to GAAP revenue reporting.
Analysts expect S&P 500 corporations in 2017 to report a total of about $1.06 trillion in GAAP net income, according to Thomson Reuters data. But allowing for nonGAAP adjustments made by many companies and analysts, total net income is expected to reach around $1.17 trillion.
Still, that 10 per cent difference between GAAP net income and the net income companies and many investors focus on is much smaller than in 2015, when the difference was 33 per cent, the largest gap since at least 2009. Last year, the difference shrank to 22 per cent.
Thomson Reuters analysed 494 S&P 500 companies and adjusted some of their fiscal years to reflect calendar years. In cases where companies and analysts focused on GAAP, that number was counted as adjusted net income.
Adding to pressure on US chief financial officers, the SEC last year sent comment letters to corporations questioning their accounting methods. It warned companies not to produce misleading quarterly reports using larger fonts and bolded type to emphasise non-GAAP metrics.
“The SEC was upset about how non-GAAP was being used, and I think people have tried to listen to that. Nobody wants an SEC comment letter,” said Takis Makridis, Chief Executive of Equity Methods, which advises companies on equity compensation. Silicon Valley’s technology giants have additional reasons to start emphasising GAAP results.
“The biggest companies who, earlier in their evolution needed to show numbers that put them in a more favourable light, no longer need that advantage,” said Pivotal Research analyst Brian Wieser. “It raises greater contrast with companies that are just emerging.”
US stocks ended down slightly after another volatile session on Friday following the latest White House shake-up and increased focus on the outlook for the Trump administration’s agenda and post-election rally.
While the day’s losses were small, Friday marked the first time stocks haven’t risen the day after a more than 1 per cent drop since Donald Trump was elected president on November 8.
Thursday’s 1.5 per cent drop in the S&P 500 came a week after a similar fall but was only the fourth decline of more than 1 per cent for the index this year.
“While this mini correction we’re seeing may not amount to much, it’s probably caused by this escalation in doubt of all of these things that seemed hopeful to investors at the beginning of the Trump administration,” said J Bryant Evan, Investment Adviser and Portfolio Manager at Cozad Asset Management, in Champaign, Illinois.
The White House said Trump on Friday fired chief strategist Steve Bannon, known as an economic nationalist and an advocate of “America First” policies. Critics have accused him of harbouring anti-Semitic and white nationalist sentiments.
While stocks turned higher as reports of Bannon’s departure began to circulate, they lost those gains heading into the close. All three major indexes posted losses for the week.