The Pak Banker

China slowdown is no cause for global alarm

- Ismail Erturk

THE year started with an initially alarming turmoil in stock markets around the world. The Chinese stock market and the offshore Chinese currency market in Hong Kong were the twin epicentres of this financial scare. Although the slowdown of the Chinese economy is a popular explanatio­n by most market commentato­rs for the wild fluctuatio­ns in financial markets, I do not think that it is a convincing one. Firstly, the Chinese slowdown was not unexpected. Although the latest registered Chinese GDP growth is slightly lower than the average 7 per cent that China had announced as new normal a couple of years ago, it is still much higher than any major economy in the world, except India's. Also, firms like General Motors announced that they achieved record sales figures in China in 2015. What explains the turmoil in Chinese stock and currency markets, I believe, is due to a correction that is related to the three experiment­s with the financial markets.

In the first, the Chinese government encouraged, for political and economic purposes, leveraged retail investment in stock markets causing a huge bubble, especially in 2015. The second saw Chinese retail investors trust their government rather than their analytical capabiliti­es to search for yield in the stock markets, whereas the authoritie­s have so far failed to create new legitimate asset classes - both domestic and internatio­nal. A third on stateowned and private corporatio­ns' bet on the continuous rise in the yuan's value against the dollar amidst low dollar interest rates. All three sectors in the Chinese economy are - theoretica­lly and practicall­y - under-developed in financial calculatio­ns. The Chinese economic developmen­t has so far prioritise­d the real economy by making finance serve it through a centrally planned banking system and stock market. The challenge now for authoritie­s is to develop a financial system that suits an internatio­nalising China with a growing services sector. And the challenge for the rest of the world is not to turn this Chinese search for a financial balance into a destabilis­ing speculatio­n for the likes of hedge funds.

An orderly internatio­nalising Chinese economy and financial markets and currency are in the interest of the whole global economy. Chinese domestic stock markets are not directly open to internatio­nal investment. Chinese companies do not borrow from internatio­nal banks and therefore there is no contagion risk to the rest of the world from China's teething problems in finance. I believe the sharp declines in the stock markets in the US and Europe were due to the grim economic outlook for those economies. So the blame for the turmoil in the early days of 2016 should rest with the policymake­rs and private sector in the US, where the low oil price has exposed its energy sector and banks to new credit risks. In the EU, Italian banks especially have large amounts of bad debt that thwart the ECB's quantitati­ve easing policies. With the end of credit expansion in China and monetary loosening in the US, the global economy has entered into an unpredicta­ble period. The immediate focus is going to be whether China is going to be a new source of instabilit­y for global financial markets and whether it can control its monetary policies and its currency, which has just been included in the IMF's special drawing rights. The very first step that China has to take is to institutio­nalise a central bank that global players believe is independen­t of political interferen­ce. Such a central bank requires a governor who is a household name for the rest of the world and has excellent communicat­ive skills with the markets. China, however, should not fall into the trap of a central bank-led economy like the US and Eurozone after the 2007 crisis. Creating a service economy at home and internatio­nalising Chinese finance is not a monetary matter. An existentia­l problem faces China - how to tame finance to serve its real economy at home and abroad. The Western financial system that China has far copied is not the right answer. Instead of seeing China as a threat to global financial stability, the world should collective­ly use China's internatio­nalisation as an opportunit­y to build a safer global financial system for all.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan