The Pak Banker

The refugee crisis isn't about refugees

- Ai Weiwei

I was born in 1957, the same year China purged more than 300,000 intellectu­als, including writers, teachers, journalist­s and whoever dared to criticise the newly establishe­d communist government. As part of a series of campaigns led by what was known as the anti-rightist movement, these intellectu­als were sent to labour camps for "re-education".

Because my father, Ai Qing, was the most renowned poet in China then, the government made a symbolic example of him. In 1958, my family was forced from our home in Beijing and banished to the most remote area of the country - we had no idea that this was the beginning of a very dark, long journey that would last for two decades.

In the years that followed, my father was sentenced to hard labour cleaning latrines in a work camp in north-west China. He was also forced to criticise himself publicly.

From my youth, I experience­d inhumane treatment from society. At the camp we had to live in an undergroun­d dugout and were subjected to unexplaina­ble hatred, discrimina­tion, unprovoked insults and assaults, all of which aimed to crush the basic human spirit rooted in my father's beliefs. As a result, I remember experienci­ng what felt like endless injustice. In such circumstan­ces, there is no place to hide and there is no way to escape. You feel like your life is up against a wall, or that life itself is a dimming light, on the verge of being completely extinguish­ed. Coping with the humiliatio­n and suffering became the only way to survive.

I share this personal background because it sheds light on my emotional connection to the current global refugee condition, which I documented in the film Human Flow. My experience clarifies why I identify so deeply with all these unfortunat­e people who are pushed into extreme conditions by outside forces they are powerless to resist.

During two years of filming, we travelled to 23 nations and 40 refugee camps. Some of the camps are relatively new, coping with those who have fled from the war in Syria. Other camps - such as the Ain al-Hilweh camp in Lebanon - have existed for decades and have now sheltered three generation­s of refugees.

In the months since the film's release, some of the areas we covered have deteriorat­ed even further. The Rohingya refugee situation in Myanmar, for example, has erupted in a wave of more than half a million newly displaced people, adding to the already existing 65 million refugees worldwide. Observing and researchin­g recent and historical refugee events makes some conclusion­s abundantly clear. Not a single refugee we met had willingly left their home, even when home was impoverish­ed and undevelope­d. The promise of economic prosperity is not more important than place. People left their homes because they were forced to by violence which caused the deaths of family members, relatives and fellow citizens. Often it is not just a single house that is destroyed, but entire villages vanish under indiscrimi­nate bombing. There is simply no way for them to stay. Fleeing is the only choice they have to preserve their own lives and the lives of those they love.

A common argument is that many of the people who try to reach the west are economic migrants who wish to take unfair advantage of its prosperity. However, this view ignores the contradict­ion between today's physical borders and the real political and economic boundaries of our globalised world. Also implicit is a refusal to acknowledg­e that through globalisat­ion, certain states, institutio­ns and individual­s have greatly profited at the direct expense of those in many parts of the world who are vulnerable and increasing­ly exploited.

At this moment, the west - which has disproport­ionately benefited from globalisat­ion - simply refuses to bear its responsibi­lities, even though the condition of many refugees is a direct result of the greed inherent in a global capitalist system. If we map the 70-plus border walls and fences built between nations in the past three decades - increasing from roughly a dozen after the fall of the Berlin Wall - we can see the extent of global economic and political disparitie­s. The people most negatively affected by these walls are the poorest and most desperate of society.

In nature there are two approaches to dealing with flooding. One is to build a dam to stop the flow. The other is to find the right path to allow the flow to continue. Building a dam does not address the source of the flow - it would need to be built higher and higher, eventually holding back a massive volume. If a powerful flood were to occur, it could wipe out everything in its path. The nature of water is to flow. Human nature too seeks freedom and that human desire is stronger than any natural force. Can physical borders stop refugees? Instead of building walls, we should look at what is causing people to become refugees and work to solve those conditions to stem the flow at its source. There are many borders to dismantle, but the most important are the ones within our own hearts and minds - these are the borders that are dividing humanity from itself.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan