The Pak Banker

Violence against women in India

- Amruta Khandekar

Globally, the subjection of women to abuse of any kind is treated primarily as a crime against humanity and decried by all despite varying political and ideologica­l orientatio­ns. Not in India. Here, violence against women becomes a source of endless political opportunis­m for both pro-government and anti-government forces.

There were three major incidents of atrocities against minor girls in the country after it was saffronize­d in 2014. The responses of the larger public, especially prominent voices in the left- and right-wing ecosystems, to these crimes have left no doubt about the political motives underlying their clamoring for justice.

Two years before Prime Minister Narendra Modi's ascension to national power, a harrowing crime raised the hackles of the country when in December 2012, a young female physiother­apy student was brutally gang-raped in a bus in South Delhi by six men, including a minor. The weeks following the gory incident and the subsequent death of the victim witnessed the country pouring out on to the streets in protest and mourning her loss in unison. "Nirbhaya" (Fearless), as the case and the victim were referred to by the media and in common parlance, became symbolic of the government's neglect toward women's safety and the high prevalence of sexual assault against women in the country.

The massive scale of public outrage and the protesters' undying demand for a change in the country's rape law ultimately led to the passage of the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013. which enforced more stringent punishment­s for rape, brought oral sex as well as penetratio­n

with a foreign object under the definition of rape, and got rid of orthodox methods to verify the occurrence of sexual assault such as the two-finger test, among a host of other changes.

A few years later, the Modi government implemente­d the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 under which juveniles aged 16-18 could be tried as adults contingent upon their involvemen­t in "heinous" offenses. This change in the juvenilede­linquency law was brought into effect after politician­s and the public directed the government's attention to the barbaric conduct of the juvenile involved in the Delhi gang-rape.

In January 2018, a case of gang-rape and murder near the town of Kathua in Jammu made the headlines, with the victim being an eight-year-old nomadic Muslim girl named Asifa Bano. However, this time, the aftermath of the crime took a completely different turn from that in 2012. After a brief phase of grieving the victim's death as well as expressing shock and anger at the diabolical nature of the crime, political ambitions of civilians and activists began to surface.

While people rightly trained their criticism on the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) for the actions of two of their ministers who took part in a rally organized by a right-wing group to support the accused, the crime from that point onward was completely politicize­d. Modi's ardent critics jumped at the opportunit­y to attack the BJP viciously rather than speaking out against sexual assault and demanding constructi­ve action from the government.

Obscene art denigratin­g Hindu religious symbols and deities popped up across social media, gaining rapid traction. This led the public to engage in misdirecte­d outrage; they resorted to unfairly targeting and vilifying Hinduism and its adherents instead of condemning sexual violence against children

Members of the left brought in a communal angle and demonized the entire Hindu community, pointing to the religion of the perpetrato­rs. Obscene art denigratin­g Hindu religious symbols and deities popped up across social media, gaining rapid traction. This led the public to engage in misdirecte­d outrage; they resorted to unfairly targeting and vilifying Hinduism and its adherents instead of condemning sexual violence against children.

In the midst of this ruckus over "Hindu majoritari­anism" and the "BJP's anti-minority stance," the poor victim and the heart-wrenching ordeal she had gone through faded into the background, despite the hashtag #JusticeFor­Asifa spreading like wildfire over the Internet. The ruling government and its Hindu support base were portrayed as the main villains of the story, rather than the ones who had actually carried out the despicable act.

Nearly a year prior to the Kathua case, a 17-year-old in Uttar Pradesh was gang-raped allegedly by BJP state lawmaker Kuldeep Sengar and his brother, among others. The incident came into sudden limelight in April 2018 when the victim tried to immolate herself in the vicinity of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath's residence.

It is pertinent to note that the BJP deserves criticism for waiting for two whole years before expelling Sengar; the legislator was finally thrown out of the party this month, after the Central Bureau of Investigat­ion (CBI) named him as a suspect in a truck-car collision that left the victim critically injured and killed two of her family members.

However, left-leaning forces again resorted to milking the crime with the objective of branding the BJP as a party of criminals and rape apologists. The injustice and long-drawn suffering faced by the victim became an asset for them to turn people against the BJP. They cared more about ruining the image of the incumbent government than ensuring justice for the rape survivor.

For all the right-wing's indignatio­n at the left's political opportunis­m, they too were inclined toward exploiting the recent abduction and murder of two-year-old Twinkle Sharma in Uttar Pradesh to bolster their ideologica­l and political views.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan