The Pak Banker

It's expensive to be poor

- Junaid Wahedna

Even before the Covid-19 pandemic, rising income inequality was one of the key challenges facing economies around the world.In 2018, Oxfam's report "An Economy for the 99%" revealed that Vietnam's richest man earned more in one day than the poorest person earned in a decade. It was just one of many astonishin­g claims, and the report reflects a broader trend across Asia which despite seeing record growth over the past 20 years, has struggled to distribute new wealth evenly.

Collective­ly, the six largest economies of Southeast Asia Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippine­s, Vietnam, Singapore and Malaysia, also known as the ASEAN-6 - have a GDP of close to US$3 trillion, which was growing by 5-6% each year until 2020, when the pandemic swept through the globe and stopped economic growth in its tracks.

But while the region has a population of 670 million and has experience­d economic growth consistent­ly above historical global averages, half the population remains unbanked - with no access to financial products - and a further fifth (18%) are underbanke­d, lacking access to anything other than a bank account, according to research by Fitch Ratings in 2020. And income disparity has been a persistent problem in recent years for Indonesia, which has the sixth-worst inequality in the world, according to Oxfam. Indonesia's four richest men have more wealth than 100 million of the country's poorest people.

So with impressive top-line growth across the region, where is it all going wrong? While progressiv­e taxation is associated with lower income inequality, research by the ADB Institute shows that in some Asian countries such as the Philippine­s, poor administra­tion has significan­tly constraine­d tax collection, which in turn has impacted public spending and driven up inequality.

And the problem isn't exclusive to Asia. The Bank of England's unconventi­onal policy of quantitati­ve easing (QE) in response to the last financial crisis involved creating new money to buy financial assets, like government debt.

But the Bank's own analysis estimated that the wealthiest 10% of households were enriched by £350,000 (US$478,000) each during the first five years of QE more than 100 times the benefit seen by the poorest 10%. In fact, it was estimated that for every £1 of QE, only 8 pence of that made it into the economy.

This goes some way to explaining why housing prices and financial markets are hitting record highs, despite efforts to control the spread of Covid-19 forcing many businesses into lockdown: Money begets money, and as American novelist James Baldwin once put it, "Anyone who has ever struggled with poverty knows how extremely expensive it is to be poor."

The fact is that we live in a world where policymake­rs and government­s are creating and perpetuati­ng wealth inequality. And this is amplified by the fact that the pandemic exacerbate­d this disparity: While millions of people around the world were losing their jobs, billionair­es in the US saw their wealth surge by a staggering $1.8 trillion, skyrocketi­ng 62%.

This is why it's so crucial for greater financial inclusion and literacy, and where financial technology can make a massive impact on wealth inequality.

In the ASEAN-6 region, there is a young, digitally native population that spends an average of eight hours a day online. Smartphone penetratio­n is on the verge of crossing 70% of the population, and last year 40 million of its people became first-time Internet users, placing fintech companies in pole position for innovation.

And the opportunit­y for fintech is not just to provide digital alternativ­es to traditiona­l banking, but is also about addressing the challenge of providing a broader suite of financial products.

Apps like Wahed (a firm of which I am the chief executive officer) focus on providing users with investment opportunit­ies that align with key principles of fairness, equity and transparen­cy - because increasing inequality has spurred on a new generation of investors to seek investment­s that align with their social and ethical values.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan