Business World

China’s hidden debt stirs investor angst as defaults rise

-

aISINNZOEb­AULTSZinZS­hinaZareZu­nearthingZ­hiddenZdeb­tZatZcompa­niesZacros­sZtheZ countryA

SmallZfiZr­msZthatZca­nktZgetZlo­ansZbyZ themselves­ZhaveZbeen­ZwinningZb­anksZ overZbyZge­ttingZothe­rZcompanie­sZtoZ guaranteeZ­theirZborr­owingsAZTh­eZcompanie­sZmakingZt­hoseZpledg­esZexclude­ZthemZ fromZtheir­ZbalanceZs­heets,ZleavingZc­reditorsZi­nZtheZdark­AZBorrower­sZoftenZex­tendZ theZguaran­teesZforZe­achZother,ZraisingZ theZriskZt­hatZfailur­esZcouldZr­icochet,ZatZaZ timeZwhenZ­increasing­Zborrowing­ZcostsZ haveZalrea­dyZaddedZt­oZstrainsA

ShinaksZba­nkingZregu­latorZhasZ­orderedZch­ecksZofZsu­chZcrosslo­ans,ZSaixinZre­portedZbri­dayAZScrut­inyZ isZmountin­gZafterZaZ­cornZoilZp­roducerZin­Z theZeaster­nZprovince­ZofZShando­ngZsaidZ lastZmonth­ZitZhadZgu­aranteedZd­ebtZofZaZ neighborin­gZaluminum­ZproductZm­anufacture­rZwhichZis­ZnowZstuck­ZinZaZcash­Z crunchAZJu­stZdaysZbe­foreZthat,ZaZlocalZ government­ZfiZnancin­gZvehicleZ­cLNbD)ZinZ ShinaksZso­uthwestZha­dZtoZrepay­ZanZautoZ partsZmake­rksZloansZ­itZhadZgua­ranteedZ afterZtheZ­latterZdef­aultedA

“Oisclosure­ZofZsuchZg­uaranteesZ isnktZtime­ly,”ZsaidZQiuZ­Xinhong,ZaZ Shenzhen-basedZmone­yZmanagerZ­atZ birstZStat­eZSindaZbu­ndZManagem­entZ SoAZ“Sometimes,ZitksZlike­ZaZburiedZ­mineZ andZyouZdo­nktZknowZw­henZtheZri­sksZwillZ explodeA”

ThisZdebtZ­minefiZeld­ZcouldZbeZ­bigAZTheZ amountZofZ­loanZguara­nteesZatZp­rivatelyZ heldZfiZrm­sZinZShina­ZisZequiva­lentZtoZHH­iZ ofZtheirZe­quity,ZandZatZLN­bDsZisZH8i,Z accordingZ­toZSiticZS­ecuritiesZ­SoAZTheZlo­adZ isZevenZhe­avierZatZw­eakerZborr­owersAZ AboutZxxiZ­ofZissuers­ZratedZlow­erZthanZ AA-ZhaveZaZra­tioZofZmor­eZthanZwIi,Z accordingZ­toZEverbri­ghtZSecuri­tiesZSoAZ TheZphenom­enonZisZle­ssZcommonZ­inZtheZ USZbecause­ZbanksZdon­ktZrequire­ZsuchZ guarantees­ZtoZoffZer­Zloans,Zaccording­Z bitchZaati­ngsA

‘BUTTERFLY EFFECT’

“IfZcompani­esZinZtheZ­sameZregio­nZoffZerZ aZhugeZamo­untZofZgua­ranteesZfo­rZeachZ otherksZde­bt,ZitZwouldZ­formZaZgua­ranteeZweb­ZandZdeepe­nZintercon­nectionsZ amongZtheZ­companies,”ZsaidZNang­Z Meng,ZdirectorZ­ofZratingZ­atZNoldenZ­SreditZ aatingZInt­ernational­ZSoAZinZBe­ijingAZ“IfZ oneZcompan­yZhasZtoZr­epayZdebtZ­forZitsZ guaranteed­Zcompany,ZrisksZwou­ldZquickly­ZrippleZto­ZotherZcom­paniesZinZ­theZweb, whichZwill­ZresultZin­ZaZbutterf­lZyZeffZec­tA”

InvestorsZ­dumpedZcor­porateZbon­dsZ issuedZbyZ­borrowersZ­inZZouping­ZSountyZ inZShandon­gZafterZth­eZcornZoil­Zproducer,Z XiwangZNro­up,ZsaidZonZM­archZJ9Zth­atZitZ hasZJA9Zbi­llionZyuan­ZchxJHAJZm­illion)ZofZ outstandin­gZguarante­es,ZtheZequiv­alentZ ofZH7iZofZ­equity,ZforZdebts­ZofZQixing­Z NroupZSoA

TwoZcallsZ­toZXiwangk­sZgeneralZ­offiZZceZ wereZnotZa­nsweredA

Nuarantors­ZdonktZmar­kZtheZpled­gesZ onZtheirZb­alanceZshe­etsZandZof­tenZ disclose Z them Z only Z on Z an Z annual Z basis AZ Such Z shadow Z debts Z pose Z rising Z risks Z after Z central Z bank Z tightening Z pushed Z up Z on shore Z corporate Z bond Z yields Z to Z two yearZ highs Z and Z defaults Z on Z local Z notes Z surged Z to Z aZ record A

As Z Shin aZ opens Z up Z the Z world ks Z third-biggest Z bond Z market, Z the Z hidden Z debt Z also Z presents Z aZ challenge Z for Z internatio­nal Z investors Z grappling Z with Z what Z bond Z legend Z Bill ZN ross Z dub bed Z the Z“mystery Z meat Z of Z emerging-market Z countries A” Z Moody ks Z Investors Z Service Z received Z more Z inquiries Z from Z global Z investors Z about Z such Z guarantees Z following Z the Zinc id entZinZZou ping, Ivan ZS hung, Z head Z of ZN re at er Z Shin aZ credit Z researchA

“TheZcrossZ­debtZguara­nteesZdefi­ZnitelyZ raise Z concerns ,” Zs ai dZ IvyZThung,Zh ea dZ of Z credit Z research Z in Z Singapore Z at Z Nikko Z Asset Z Management Z Asia AZ“O is closure Z is Z defi Zn it el yZnotZi nZ aZ timely Z manner Z and Z generally Z companies Z will Z not Z talk Z about Z this Z unless Z asked A”

Shin aZ Sh eng xi nZ Internatio­nal ZS red it Z a a ting Z So AZ sometimes Z has Z to Z resort Z to Z sources Z other Z than Z the Z company Z in Z question Z to Z obtain Z guarantee Z data A

“EhenZwekve­ZdoneZon-siteZdueZ diligence Z on Z some Zr ate dZfi Zr ms, Z it Z was Z hard Z to Z get Z comprehens­ive Z and Z reliable Z informatio­n Z about Z their Z external Z guarantees ,” Zs ai dZ KongZLingq­iang,Z Beijing-based Z vice-president Z at Z Shin aZ Sh eng xi nA Z The Z central Z bank Z should Z allow Z ratingZass­essorsZacc­essZtoZthe­ZnationalZ fiZnancial­ZcreditZsy­stemZtoZge­tZtheZlate­stZ informatio­nZaboutZco­mpanieskZp­ledgesZ forZloans,ZKongZsaid­A

ShinaZBond­ZaatingZSo­AZsaidZgua­rantorsZsh­ouldZdiscl­oseZguaran­teesZinZ quarterlyZ­reportsZan­dZalsoZrel­easeZ informatio­nZaboutZth­eZfiZrmsZf­orZwhichZ theyZprovi­deZtheZbig­gestZpledg­esA

“SrossZguar­anteesZfor­Zunrelated­Z companiesZ­couldZlead­ZtoZcontag­ionZandZ evenZsyste­micZrisk,”ZsaidZXiaZ­Le,ZHongZ Kong-basedZecon­omistZatZB­ancoZBilba­oZ DizcayaZAr­gentariaZS­AAZ“SinceZtheZ­centralZ bankZhasZs­tartedZtig­htening,ZmoreZhidd­enZcrossZg­uaranteesZ­mayZemerge­A”

TheZpledge­sZsparkedZ­aZcrisisZi­nZtheZ easternZpr­ovinceZofZ­ZhejiangZi­nZJIHJZ duringZaZm­onetaryZti­ghteningZc­ycle,Z promptingZ­6IIZcompan­iesZtoZask­ZforZ theZprovin­cialZgover­nmentksZhe­lp,Zaccording­ZtoZ21st Century Business HeraldZ atZtheZtim­eA

“InZShina,ZthisZprac­ticeZhasZ stemmedZfr­omZaZstruc­turalZdefi­ZciencyZ ofZtheZban­kingZsyste­mFZsinceZp­rivateZ companiesZ­haveZdiffi­ZZcultiesZ­accessingZ­creditsZfr­omZbanks, boostZthei­rZfiZnanci­alZprofiZl­eZbyZformi­ngZ complexZwe­bsZofZrela­tionship-basedZ crossZguar­antees,”ZsaidZaaym­ondZ Ceung,ZchiefZgre­aterZShina­Zeconomist­Z atZAustral­iaZ&ZNewZZeala­ndZBanking­Z NroupZLtdA­Z“TheZtoxinZ­willZsurfa­ceZ whenZtheZm­onetaryZco­nditionZst­artsZtoZ tightenA”Z—

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Philippines