Indian protests growing as ‘anti-farm’ peace offer nixed
New laws ‘could leave farmers landless, at mercy of corporate players’
Farmers’ protests across the the Indian capital New Delhi have gained momentum as several new groups joined from various parts of the country on Wednesday.
Protesters repeated their demands for the government to scrap new agricultural laws which they say could destroy their livelihoods by opening up the sector to private players.
However, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government argues that the laws passed in September would allow farmers to be self-sufficient by setting their prices and selling produce directly to private firms, such as supermarket chains. Farmers are not buying that and say that the new laws would instead pave the way for the government to stop buying the crops at guaranteed prices, leaving them at the “mercy of private buyers” fixing prices.
Bhanu Pratar Singh, president of the Indian Farmers’ Association, said: “Our basic demand is that the government gives us in writing that the Minimum Support Price (MSP) that the government gives to farm produce should be codified in law in the farm laws.”
Protests escalated last week when tens of thousands of farmers marched to New Delhi, with a majority saying that the new laws would also allow traders to stockpile grains, which they fear will lead to rising prices and more profit for traders amid the coronavirus pandemic.
The demonstrations led to clashes with police, who used tear gas, water cannons and batons against protesters.
Farmers sell their products at wholesale markets owned by the government, which also sets the MSP for grains.
All of that could change with the entry of new market players in the agricultural sector, where individual market prices could supersede the MSP, Jagjit Singh Dalewal of the Indian Farmers’ Union, a joint forum for 30 farm unions, told Arab News. “It will leave us at the mercy of the big business houses. We don’t want that uncertainty,” he said. “The traditional market system and the MSP have sustained farmers in Punjab and Haryana for a long time. They assured us a guaranteed price which is higher than the market. The new farm laws deprive us of that,” Dalewal added. On Tuesday, talks between officials and the farmers’ union failed after the latter rejected an offer to establish a committee on the issue. A joint statement released by farmers’ groups said that they found the offer “an attempt to buy time without addressing the real issue.”
The next round of talks is expected to begin on Thursday.
“Most of the farmers in India have small landholding, and they
cannot compete with the big corporate houses,” Sunil Pradhan, a farmer based in Greater Noida, a suburban city of Delhi, told Arab News.
“A farmer having less than two hectares of land cannot have bargaining power with the corporate groups. He will succumb to pressure and become a pawn in the hands of the big players. Such farmers need government protection,” he added.
The government says that the new laws are not “anti-farmer.” “The new agricultural law implemented by the government is not anti-farmer at all,” Information and Technology Minister Ravi Shankara Prasad said on Wednesday. “Under this bill, the safety net of the MSP will remain and will also add new options that the farmers have. Farmers will be able to enter into direct agreements for sale of food grains with production companies,” he tweeted on Wednesday. Economists have questioned the claims, drawing attention to the “genuine” concerns of farmers. “Many small farmers are worried that the free market in the agriculture sector will dispossess many small farmers of their lands, which will become corporatized, and they will become landless,” New Delhi-based Prof. Arun Kumar of Jawaharlal Nehru University, told Arab News.
“The government is not doing enough to address the existential concerns of the farmers,” he added. Kumar said that “86 percent of the farmers are small farmers and cultivate less than 2 hectares of land.”