The Edge Singapore

What Audi and Porsche stand to gain from joining Formula 1

Much about the deal remains unclear — and to see upside, they’ve got to win

- BY HANNAH ELLIOTT

The announceme­nt that Porsche and Audi want to lend their names to Formula 1 comes at a high point of popularity in the US for the world’s most glamorous racing series. Miami’s first-ever F1 Grand Prix was held on May 8. Race-day ticket prices hit US$1,342 ($1,860), more than prices for the NBA finals, Stanley Cup, and World Series, according to the ticket-seller TickPick. Luxe hotel, restaurant, and entertainm­ent packages were selling for as much as US$110,000. More than 240,000 fans attended the sold-out event, with 82,500 surroundin­g the track in Hard Rock Stadium.

Experts credit the popular Netflix documentar­y Formula One: Drive To Survive with stirring a surge of US interest in the once-obscure sport founded in Europe in the 1950s.

“The F1 Grand Prix has always been a popular event, but it hasn’t become the story that this Miami Formula 1 race has been,” says Brett Goldberg, co-founder and co-CEO of TickPick. “A fair amount of it was the success of the Netflix documentar­y. That itself has brought massive awareness to the US.”

Race organisers in Miami have said they plan to increase capacity in coming seasons. A second new American race is scheduled for November 2023 in Las Vegas.

How they’ll do it

Much remains unclear about what it will mean for Porsche and Audi as they buy their way into the prestige of a sport that reported annual revenue of US$2.136 billion across its 22-race calendar in 2021. The series made US$92 million in profits that year after losing US$386 million during 2020. Race promotion — companies and promoters paying to be associated with F1’s grandeur — was the biggest revenue stream, accounting for 40% of total income. Qatar, for instance, pays US$55 million per year for its contract to host F1 — the highest amount on the list of contract costs; Mexico pays US$25 million.

There are three ways Audi and Porsche could enter such a blue-blooded field. They have already supplied engines to other teams. This year, for instance, Mercedes supplied engines to four of the 10 teams on the F1 grid; Porsche briefly supplied turbocharg­ed engines to McLaren in the 1980s and to a team called Footwork (formerly Arrows) in the early 1990s.

Stronger options are to buy an existing team and use that platform for their own engineerin­g, or to launch a bona fide factory team, like Ferrari’s, which would demand hundreds of millions of dollars in research, engineerin­g and other investment — not to mention years of time refining the new technology for a race.

Spokespeop­le from both brands declined to answer questions about whether joining F1 means launching such a team, or if they would go another route such as supplying engines and technology for others.

It was earlier reported that Porsche is considerin­g providing power units to Red Bull. Porsche’s plans, while unannounce­d, are “quite concrete”, said parentgrou­p Volkswagen AG’s (VW) CEO, Herbert Diess. Audi’s plans are less advanced, though progressin­g, Diess said. Audi may offer around US$556.3 million to acquire McLaren as a means to enter, according to some reports.

“Both premium brands see it as the right decision [to join F1] and are prioritisi­ng it,” Diess said during a town-hall discussion in Wolfsburg, Germany, on May 1. He declined to specify the timing or exact nature of the commitment.

A moneymakin­g opportunit­y

There is clearly potential to leverage newly minted American F1 fans into conquests for VW’s highly profitable premium car brands. Winning in Formula 1 bolsters brand image and awareness across multiple segments of consumers, Goldberg says, which translates to car sales. It is no coincidenc­e that some of the coolest inventions now popular on modern sports cars — big

rear wings, paddle-shifting and carbonfibr­e elements to help increase efficiency — directly descended from F1 cars.

“Your [potential] Porsche enthusiast, your sports car enthusiast — they don’t always translate to Nascar, but they do translate to Formula 1,” he says. “That’s a wealthy group of individual­s.”

In addition to potential car sales, Porsche and Audi teams could make money from co-branding and sponsorshi­ps. The most successful racing teams such as Ferrari, Mercedes and Red Bull count multimilli­on-dollar deals with sponsors and advertiser­s like Oracle, Puma, Tag Heuer and Walmart. In February, Red Bull Racing signed a single sponsorshi­p deal worth US$150 million with Bybit, a Singapore-based cryptocurr­ency platform.

They could also win hundreds of millions of dollars in prize money. Roughly 47.5% of F1 profit makes up the prize money, which is then divided into two categories: Half goes to the F1 and its shareholde­rs; half goes to the teams, which divvy it up based on final standings for the year.

“The sport in North America [is] under-viewed, under-monetised, underevery­thing,” said Greg Maffei, the president and CEO of Liberty Media, which owns F1. “I don’t think that gets solved in a week, but I think that’s an interestin­g long-term opportunit­y.”

A risky bet on a marketing goldmine

There are some risks to joining F1, especially for Porsche, which built its brand image on the plucky race cars and rallies of the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s. For the power brokers at VW, the old adage “win on Sunday, sell on Monday” still holds true. (Cars that win races instil consumers with a favourable view of their brands and make people want to drive the street-legal cousins of the winning cars.)

“We are assuming that in 2026 or 2028, Formula 1 will be the biggest motorsport spectacle in the world — even more than today — bigger in China, bigger in the United States,” Diess said. “And with that, also the largest marketing platform for premium vehicles.”

But “win” is the operationa­l word.

For Porsche, which got mixed results in Formula E and races only occasional­ly, in lesser-known series such as Le Mans, entering F1 but faring poorly would potentiall­y hurt the image of VW group’s most profitable brand. Porsche has built its allure on the back of a highly successful (non-F1) racing car, the 911.

As Porsche’s most profitable vehicle, the 911 contribute­s 11% of Porsche sales by volume while accounting for roughly 30% of earnings.

Aston Martin, for instance, has suffered this season as its drivers continue to finish at the back of the pack. While the company also faces other headwinds, such as a disappoint­ing initial public offering and subsequent churning of top management, the fact that the British brand is currently ranked ninth of 10 teams does not help morale among loyal fans, or win new ones for the brand. On May 4, Aston Martin Lagonda named former Ferrari NV boss Amedeo Felisa as top executive. Felisa immediatel­y replaced Tobias Moers, who joined the company in 2020 from Mercedes-Benz’s high-performanc­e AMG brand. Rumours have circulated for months that Aston Martin racing team owner Lawrence Stroll is looking to sell it.

A proven record

Ferrari provides the gold-standard case study for the power of F1. It is the world’s strongest brand in all categories for nearly a decade, according to the Annual Brand Ranking report that balances scorecard of metrics evaluating marketing investment, stakeholde­r equity and business performanc­e. Ferrari makes just over 11,000 cars per year but trades on a gargantuan footprint of loyalty, heritage, and a winning tradition bolstered largely by its longstandi­ng involvemen­t in F1. Cumulative­ly, the Italian supercar maker and racing team are worth more than US$27 billion.

“The embodiment of luxury, Ferrari continues to be admired and desired around the world,” wrote David Haigh, the CEO of Brand Finance. “It is no wonder that many consumers, who might never own a Ferrari car, want a bag or a watch emblazoned with the Prancing Horse.”

The success of Ferrari’s racing cars on the track in the 1950s and 1960s built the fame and reputation that fuelled the appetite for the brand’s first popular roadgoing cars; its million-dollar icons such as the F40 drew close parallels to the race cars of the 1980s. Its fans, known as Tifosi, are the most notorious force behind any F1 team on the planet. In 2017, one in three F1 fans described themselves as Ferrari supporters, according to a F1 fan survey in 2021.

The caveat is that on the world’s bestknown race track, you’ve got to win to stay popular —and feel you’re getting your money’s worth from the more than US$145 million budget required to field a team. In the years since 2017, Ferrari has fallen off its competitiv­e race pace and has lacked the star power of a driver such as Mercedes’ Lewis Hamilton. It’s no coincidenc­e that last year, just 18% — fewer than one in five — of racing fans still described themselves as supporters of the brand. (Sales of Ferrari street cars nonetheles­s rose.) Close observers might observe a bump in popularity after this year: Ferrari is currently running in first place in the constructo­rs team standings.

Selling electric in 2026

There’s also the question of how entering an old, fossil-fuelled race series could help sell electric vehicles, which Audi and Porsche have committed to selling extensivel­y. The brands have timed any move carefully. A rule change stipulates that in 2026, all F1 race cars will have new engines that are more electrifie­d and run on synthetic fuel.

The adjustment levels the playing field for any brands that might want to enter the series. All will be building engines to comply with the rule change.

“You can’t enter Formula 1 unless a technology window opens up, which means, in order to get in there, a rule change so that everyone starts again from the same place,” Diess said.

It was unclear whether ownership of Rimac, a Croatian battery provider and automaker, might play a role in Porsche’s moves to develop technology for itself or others in the series. A spokespers­on for Porsche declined to say whether making an F1 move means Porsche would withdraw from Formula E.

Diess, for his part, was more direct. “It’s really only Formula 1 that counts,” he said. “If you do motorsport, you should do Formula 1, as that’s where the impact is greatest.” —

 ?? ??
 ?? PICTURES: BLOOMBERG ??
PICTURES: BLOOMBERG
 ?? ??
 ?? PICTURES: BLOOMBERG ??
PICTURES: BLOOMBERG

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Singapore