Business Day

Dump junk intelligen­ce

- W Davies-Webb Saxonwold YOUR LETTERS: Letters of more than 300 words will be edited for length. Letters should be sent by e-mail to busday@bdfm.co.za or faxed to (011) 280-5505. E-mailed letters are preferred. Anonymous correspond­ence will not be publis

The US intelligen­ce community hit a new credibilit­y low when it saw fit to draft a twopage summary of a 35-page document on the alleged “capture” of president-elect Donald Trump by the Kremlin, reportedly compiled by a “former British Intelligen­ce official”, and presented it to both President Barack Obama and Trump.

The document, allegedly compiled for some of Trump’s Republican Party opponents in the primaries, has reportedly been circulatin­g at the highest levels of the US government and media for some months now, but had not been quoted given its unverifiab­le status. Even the Hillary Clinton campaign avoided its use.

However, the US intelligen­ce community saw fit to use the report to bolster the propaganda war being waged against Trump by the US establishm­ent and mainstream media, to desperatel­y prove that he is Putin’s lapdog.

Having already failed to prove conclusive­ly that Russia hacked the Democratic Party’s servers (the party refused to hand the servers over to the FBI for forensic analysis to prove such allegation­s), the US intelligen­ce establishm­ent, with billions of dollars at its disposal, relied instead on the musings of a foreign national to take yet another moribund pot-shot at the Trump-Putin link.

So while Trump was reportedly briefed on the contents of this report last Friday, the US Federal Bureau of Investigat­ion has yet to even verify the contents of such explosive allegation­s. A basic rule of intelligen­ce gathering is verificati­on of the facts, which in this instance was seemingly junked by the US intelligen­ce establishm­ent.

This kindergart­en effort would be laughable were it not for the serious ramificati­ons that such sloppy investigat­ive assessment­s can have on US decision-making. It follows a long road of US intelligen­ce failures including the determinat­ion that Iraq had weapons of mass destructio­n, its failure to stop the 9/11 attack on New York, despite evidence that such planning was taking place, despite making false allegation­s that Iraq had links with al-Qaeda following 9/11, and “politicisi­ng” and deliberate­ly underestim­ating the strength of Isis and Al-Nusra in Iraq and Syria.

An appropriat­e ending for this unverifiab­le intelligen­ce evaluation is the dustbin. Its authors should be “fired” by incoming president Trump himself.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa