SVB vacuum and judiciary plans hit Israel’s tech sector
Proposals to give state greater say in selecting judges while curbing court powers worry investors
After weathering recession and military conflicts, Israel’s hi-tech sector could be facing its biggest test as the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) removes a key funding source and a proposed judicial overhaul threatens the bedrock of corporate law.
Nicknamed “Start-up Nation”, Israel’s economy has ridden a wave of tech success with a sector that employs just 10% of the workforce accounting for about 15% of economic output, more than half of exports and a quarter of tax income.
But proposals by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s hard-right coalition to give the government a greater say in the selection of new judges while limiting the Supreme Court’s power to strike down legislation have worried existing and potential investors.
“The high-tech sector needs stability, needs the rules of the game to be clear, needs a certainty that … they will have the court to go to,” said Karnit Flug, a former Bank of Israel governor who is now a vice-president at the Israel Democracy Institute, adding that in the absence of those investors would be reluctant to commit funds.
There is also the risk of accelerating a brain drain. An estimated 100,000 Israelis already live and work in California’s Silicon Valley and many others have moved to Europe. In an industry of about 400,000 there are now about 6,000 vacant tech jobs, according to government data.
“This sector … would take their brains … their ideas, their entrepreneurship, and there will be a red carpet laid out for them in some countries,” Flug told the Israel Council on Foreign Relations.
Parliament has given preliminary approval to the proposed legislation, hailed by proponents as necessary to curb what they deem an activist judiciary that interferes in politics while opponents call it a threat to democracy, but final approval has been delayed for a month after widespread protests.
WATCHING
A number of high-tech firms such as US-Israeli cybersecurity start-up Wiz have said they would pull money from Israel and keep funds from entering the country if the reforms pass, while the head of cloud-based software provider NICE said major investors are carefully watching the situation.
Meanwhile, the shekel has dropped to a three-year low versus the US dollar on expectations of a drop in foreign direct investment from $15bn last year and a record $27bn in 2021.
According to the IVC Research Centre and LeumiTech, Israeli high-tech firms raised $1.7bn in the first quarter, down 70% from the $5.8bn in the first three months of 2022 and its lowest quarterly fundraising level in four years.
Adding to the tech sector ’ s worries is the collapse of US lender SVB, which Jon Medved, CEO of investment firm OurCrowd, called “the go-to bank” for Israeli start-ups — a 7,000strong group including “unicorns” with a valuation of at least $1bn and smaller companies with less than 50 employees.
More than half of the country’s start-ups held an account with SVB, companies and venture capital investors said, in some cases their only US banking facility, though the amounts involved are not fully known.
Mickey Balter, CEO of indoor navigation start-up Oriient, said SVB was the firm’s only US bank and it was fortunate to transfer 70% of the millions of dollars it had there back to Israel, leaving the rest at SVB.
Initially, Balter thought the remaining 30% was lost but he regained access once regulators took over. “It would have been very painful,” he said. “Before [the regulators took over] I foresaw a scenario where we lost most of our operating cash.”
Israel’s Bank Leumi said it was able to move $1bn back to local accounts before US regulators took control, about half the amount estimated to have been returned, according to investors.
Tech companies and investors alike said SVB was a rarity in the banking industry, familiar with Israel’s tech ecosystem and offering loan terms unmatched by other banks. “These guys were very professional and lovely to work with … Banks today can be a pain … These guys weren’t,” Medved said.
Citing the judicial reforms, Adam Fisher, a partner at investment firm Bessemer Venture Partners, said fewer US banks may be willing to lend to Israeli companies, which means less competition and more onerous terms. “Locals will step in to a certain extent but they can’t grow their loan books overnight,” he said.
REGISTER
A top executive at an Israeli bank said that while he saw an opportunity to boost lending to startups, local banks alone would not be able to fill the vacuum left by SVB.
“We don’t have the ambition of billions of dollars but we certainly have the ambition to double or triple the portfolio,” the executive said.
Israel’s tech firms are therefore likely to flock to register as US companies, while keeping research & development back home, said Yaron Samid, managing partner of the TechAviv Founder Partners fund.
A handful of large US banks have offered deposit accounts to those affected by SVB’s failure, Samid said, while fintech firm Brex said it had too. Others have offered emergency liquidity but at higher rates.
“No doubt there’s a bunch of companies that only survived because of SVB’s credit facilities,” Samid said. “There’s going to be some pruning. It was already happening because of the macro dynamics and private equity markets, but this is only going to accelerate it.”
Declining to name specific companies at their own request, Samid said some Israeli start-up founders were in the “advanced stages” of negotiating investments, only for potential funders to pull out or ask for more time due to the proposed reforms.
“Good companies are going to survive,” he added. “But companies that are not as healthy are not going to survive.”